<GetPassage xmlns:tei="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0" xmlns="http://chs.harvard.edu/xmlns/cts">
            <request>
                <requestName>GetPassage</requestName>
                <requestUrn>urn:cts:latinLit:phi1254.phi001.perseus-eng1:7.5</requestUrn>
            </request>
            <reply>
                <urn>urn:cts:latinLit:phi1254.phi001.perseus-eng1:7.5</urn>
                <passage>
                    <TEI xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><text xml:lang="eng"><body><div type="translation" xml:lang="eng" n="urn:cts:latinLit:phi1254.phi001.perseus-eng1"><div type="textpart" n="7" subtype="book"><div type="textpart" n="5" subtype="chapter"><head>V</head><milestone unit="section" n="5arg"/><!--<argument>--><p>An error of the jurist Alfenus in the interpretation of early words.</p><!--</argument>--><p><milestone unit="section" n="1"/>THE jurist Alfenus, a pupil of Servius Sulpicius and a man greatly interested in matters antiquarian,  <pb n="v2.p.105"/>  in the thirty-fourth book of his <hi rend="italic">Digests</hi> and the second of his <hi rend="italic">Miscellanies,</hi> says:

<note>Fr. 1, Huschke; Resp. 14, Dig. 99, Bremer (i, pp. 287,322, 330).</note>
<quote>In a treaty which was made between the Roman people and the Carthaginians the provision is found, that the Carthaginians should pay each year to the Roman people a certain weight of <hi rend="italic">argenti puri puti,</hi> and the meaning of <hi rend="italic">puri puti</hi> was asked. I replied,</quote> he says, <quote>that <hi rend="italic">putus</hi> meant very pure,' just as we say <hi rend="italic">novicius</hi> for <hi rend="italic">novus</hi> (new) and <hi rend="italic">propicius</hi> for <hi rend="italic">proprius</hi> (proper), when we wish to augment and amplify the meaning of <hi rend="italic">novus</hi> and <hi rend="italic">proprius.</hi></quote></p><p>Upon reading this, I was surprised that Alfenus should think that the relation of <hi rend="italic">purus</hi> and <hi rend="italic">putus</hi> was the same as that of <hi rend="italic">novicius</hi> and <hi rend="italic">novus;</hi> for if the word were <hi rend="italic">puricius,</hi> then it would indeed appear to be formed like <hi rend="italic">novicius.</hi> It was also surprising that he thought that <hi rend="italic">novicius</hi> was used to imply amplification, since in fact <hi rend="italic">novicius</hi> does not mean <quote>more new,</quote> but is merely a derivative and variant of <hi rend="italic">novus.</hi> Accordingly, I agree with those who think that <hi rend="italic">putus</hi> is derived from <hi rend="italic">puto</hi> and therefore pronounce the word with the first syllable short, not long as Alfenus seems to have thought it, since he wrote that <hi rend="italic">putus</hi> came from <hi rend="italic">purus.</hi> Moreover, the earlier writers used <hi rend="italic">putare</hi> of removing and pruning away from anything whatever was superfluous and unnecessary, or even injurious and foreign, leaving only what seemed useful and without blemish. For that was the meaning of <hi rend="italic">putare,</hi> <quote>to prune,</quote> as applied to trees and vines, and so too as used of accounts.

<note>That is, to clear one's accounts.</note>
The verb <hi rend="italic">puto</hi> itself also, which we use for the purpose of stating our opinion, certainly means nothing else than that in an obscure and difficult matter we do our best, by cutting away and lopping  <pb n="v2.p.107"/>  off false views, to retain what seems true and pure and sound. Therefore in the treaty with Carthage silver was called <hi rend="italic">putum,</hi> as having been thoroughly purified and refined, as free from all foreign matter, and as spotless and whitened by the removal from it of all impurities.</p><p>But the expression <hi rend="italic">purum putum</hi> occurs, not only in the treaty with Carthage, but also in many other early writings, including the tragedy of Quintus Ennius entitled <hi rend="italic">Alexander,</hi>

<note>62, Ribbeck<hi rend="sup">3</hi>.</note>
and the satire of Marcus Varro called <foreign xml:lang="grc">Di\s Pai=des oi( Ge/rontes,</foreign>

<note>Fr. 91, Bücheler.</note>
or <hi rend="italic">Old Men are Children for a Second Time.</hi></p></div></div></div></body></text></TEI>
                </passage>
            </reply>
            </GetPassage>