<GetPassage xmlns:tei="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0" xmlns="http://chs.harvard.edu/xmlns/cts">
            <request>
                <requestName>GetPassage</requestName>
                <requestUrn>urn:cts:latinLit:phi0914.phi001.perseus-eng3:9.8-9.17</requestUrn>
            </request>
            <reply>
                <urn>urn:cts:latinLit:phi0914.phi001.perseus-eng3:9.8-9.17</urn>
                <passage>
                    <TEI xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><text><body><div n="urn:cts:latinLit:phi0914.phi001.perseus-eng3" type="edition" xml:lang="eng"><div n="9" subtype="book" type="textpart"><div n="8" subtype="chapter" type="textpart"><div n="1" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p>They<note anchored="true" type="sum" resp="ed" place="unspecified">Discussion in the Senate.</note> entered upon the active duties of
							their office on the very day of their election, for so had the senate
							decreed, and after disposing of the business connected with their
							accession to office, they proceeded at once to introduce the subject of
							the capitulation of Caudium. </p></div><div n="2" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Publilius, who was the presiding consul, called upon Spurius Postumius
							to speak. He rose in his place with just the same expression that he had
							worn when passing under the yoke, and began: </p></div><div n="3" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> “Consuls, I am quite aware that I have been called upon to speak
							first, not because I am foremost in honour, but because I am foremost in
							disgrace and hold the position not of a senator but of a man on his
							trial who has to meet the charge not only of an unsuccessful war but
							also of an ignominious peace. </p></div><div n="4" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Since, however, you have not introduced the question of our guilt or
							punishment, I shall not enter upon a defence which in the presence of
							men not unacquainted with the mutability of human fortunes would not be
							a very difficult one to undertake. I will state in a few words what I
							think about the question before us, and you will he able to judge from
							what I say whether it was myself or your legions that I spared when I
							pledged myself to the convention, however shameful or however necessary
							it was. </p></div><div n="5" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> This convention, however, was not made by the order of the Roman people,
							and therefore the Roman people are not bound by it, nor is anything due
							to the Samnites under its terms beyond our own persons. </p></div><div n="6" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Let us be surrendered by the fetials, stripped and bound; let us release
							the people from their religious obligations if we have involved them in
							any, so that without infringing any law human or divine we may resume a
							war which will be justified by the law of nations and sanctioned by the
							gods. </p></div><div n="7" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> I advise, that in the meantime the consuls enrol and equip an army and
							lead it forth to war, but that they do not cross the hostile frontier
							until all our obligations under the terms of surrender have been
							discharged. </p></div><div n="8" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> And you, immortal gods, I pray and beseech, that as it was not your will
							that the consuls Sp. Postumius and T. Veturius </p></div><div n="9" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> should wage a successful war against the Samnites, you may at least deem
							it enough to have witnessed us sent under the yoke and compelled to
							submit to a shameful convention, enough to witness us surrendered, naked
							and in chains, to the enemy, taking upon our heads the whole weight of
							his anger and vengeance! </p></div><div n="10" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> May it be in accordance with your will that the legions of Rome under
							fresh consuls should wage war against the Samnites in the same way in
							which all wars were waged before we were consuls!” </p></div><div n="11" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p>When he finished speaking, such admiration and pity were felt for him
							that they could hardly think that it was the same Sp. Postumius who had
							concluded such a disgraceful peace. </p></div><div n="12" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> They viewed with the utmost sadness the prospect of such a man suffering
							at the hands of the enemy such terrible punishment as he was sure to
							meet with, enraged as they would be at the rupture of the peace. </p></div><div n="13" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p>The whole House expressed in terms of the highest praise their approval
							of his proposal. They were beginning to vote on the question when two of
							the tribunes of the plebs, L. Livius and Q. Maelius, entered a protest
							which they afterwards withdrew. </p></div><div n="14" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> They argued that the people as a whole would not be discharged from
							their religious obligation by this surrender unless the Samnites were
							placed in the same position of advantage which they held at Caudium.
						</p></div><div n="15" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Further, they said they did not deserve any punishment for having saved
							the Roman army by undertaking to procure peace,<note anchored="true" n="3" resp="ed" place="unspecified">Livy evidently assumes that
								these two tribunes of the plebs were with the army, a most unusual
								arrangement, as they were supposed to be watching over the interests
								of the plebs within the walls of Rome. But the whole strength of
								Rome, i. e., the great majority of the plebeians, were at Caudium,
								so the presence of all the tribunes in the City might not have been
								necessary.</note> and they urged as a final reason that as they, the
							tribunes, were sacrosanct and their persons inviolable they could not be
							surrendered to the enemy or exposed to any violence. </p></div></div><div n="9" subtype="chapter" type="textpart"><div n="1" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p>To this Postumius replied: “In the meanwhile, surrender us, whom
							no inviolability protects and whose surrender will violate no man's
							conscience. </p></div><div n="2" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Afterwards you will surrender those “sacrosanct” gentlemen
							also as soon as their year of office expires, but if you take my advice
							you will see that before they are surrendered they are scourged in the
							Forum by way of paying interest for a punishment that will have been
							delayed. </p></div><div n="3" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Why, who is so ignorant of fetial law as not to see that these men are
							saying this, not because it represents the fact but to prevent their
							being surrendered? </p></div><div n="4" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> I do not deny, senators, that where the pledged words of men are held to
							possess a binding force only second to the sanctions of religion, then
							such undertakings as we have given are as sacred as formal treaties. But
							I do say that without the express order of the people nothing can be
							ratified which can bind the people. </p></div><div n="5" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Suppose the Samnites, in the same spirit of insolent pride in which they
							extorted this capitulation from us, had compelled us to recite the
							formula for the surrender of cities,<note anchored="true" n="4" resp="ed" place="unspecified">For this formula, see Vol. I. p. 45.</note>
							would you say, tribunes, that the Roman people was surrendered and that
							this City with its shrines and temples, its territory, and its waters
							had become the property of the Samnites? I say no more about surrender,
							because what we are considering is the pledge we gave in the
							capitulation. </p></div><div n="6" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Well now, suppose we had given a pledge that the Roman people would
							abandon this City, would burn it, would no longer have its own
							magistrates and senates and laws, but would live under the rule of
							kings. “Heaven forbid!” you say. </p></div><div n="7" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Yes, but the binding force of a capitulation is not lightened by the
							humiliating nature of its terms. If the people can be bound by any
							article, it can by all. The point which some consider important, namely
							whether it is a consul or a Dictator or a praetor who has given the
							undertaking is of no weight whatever. </p></div><div n="8" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> The Samnites themselves made this clear, for it was not enough for them
							that the consuls pledged themselves, they compelled the staff-officers,
							the quaestors, and the military tribunes to do the same.” </p></div><div n="9" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> “Now no one need say to me, “Why did you pledge yourself
							in that way, seeing that a consul has no right to do so and you were not
							in a position to promise them a peace of which you could not guarantee
							the ratification, or to act on behalf of the people when they had given
							you no mandate to do so?” </p></div><div n="10" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Nothing that happened at Caudium, senators, was dictated by human
							prudence; the gods deprived both the enemy's commanders and your own of
							their senses. We did not exercise sufficient caution in our various
							movements, they in their folly threw away a victory when they had won
							through our folly. </p></div><div n="11" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> They hardly felt safe on the very ground which gave them their victory,
							such a hurry were they in to agree to any conditions if only they could
							deprive of their arms men who were home to arms. </p></div><div n="12" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> If they had been in their senses, would they have had any difficulty in
							sending envoys to Rome whilst they were fetching an old man from his
							home to advise them? Was it impossible for them to enter into
							negotiations with the senate and with the people about securing peace
							and making a treaty? </p></div><div n="13" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> It is a three days' journey for lightly-equipped horsemen, and in the
							meantime there would have been an armistice until the envoys returned
							bringing either peace or the certainty of their victory. Then and then
							only would there have been a binding agreement, because we should have
							made it by order of the people. </p></div><div n="14" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> But you would not have made such an order, nor should we have given such
							a pledge. It was not the will of heaven that there should be any other
							result than this, namely, that the Samnites should be vainly deluded by
							a dream too delightful for their minds </p></div><div n="15" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> to grasp, that the same Fortune which had imprisoned our army should
							also release it, that an illusory victory should be rendered futile by a
							still more illusory peace, and that stipulations should be brought in,
							binding on none but those who actually made them. </p></div><div n="16" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> For what share have you, senators, what share has the people in this
							business? Who can call you to account, who can say that you have
							deceived him? The enemy? You have given no pledge to the enemy. Any
							fellow-citizen? You have not empowered my fellow-citizen to give a
							pledge on your behalf. </p></div><div n="17" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> You are not in my way involved with us, for you have given us no
							mandate; you are not answerable to the Samnites, for you have had no
							dealings with them. </p></div><div n="18" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> It is we who are answerable, pledged as debtors and quite able to
							discharge the debt in respect of what is our own, which we are prepared
							to pay, that is, our own persons and lives. On these let them wreak
							their vengeance, for these let them sharpen their swords and their rage.
						</p></div><div n="19" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> As for the tribunes,. you ought to consider whether it is possible for
							them to be surrendered at once, or whether it ought to be deferred, but
							as for us, T. Veturius and the rest of you who are concerned, let us in
							the meantime offer these worthless lives of ours in discharge of our
							bond, and by our deaths set free the arms of Rome for action.”
						</p></div></div><div n="10" subtype="chapter" type="textpart"><div n="1" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p>Both<note anchored="true" type="sum" resp="ed" place="unspecified">Postumius' Advice taken.</note> the speech and the speaker produced
							a great impression on all who heard him, including the tribunes, who
							were so far influenced by what they had heard that they formally placed
							themselves at the disposal of the senate. </p></div><div n="2" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> They immediately resigned their office and were handed over to the
							fetials to be conducted with the rest to Caudium. After the senate had
							passed their resolution, it seemed as though the light of day was once
							more shining on the State. </p></div><div n="3" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> The name of Postumius was in all men's mouths, he was extolled to the
							skies, his conduct was put on a level with the selfsacrifice of P.
							Decius and other splendid deeds of heroism. </p></div><div n="4" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> It was through his counsel and assistance, men said, that the State had
							found its way out of a dishonourable and guilty peace; he was exposing
							himself to the rage of the enemy and all the tortures they could inflict
							as an expiatory victim for the Roman people. </p></div><div n="5" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> All eyes were turned to arms and war; “shall we ever be
							allowed,” they exclaimed, “to meet the Samnites in
							arms?” </p></div><div n="6" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p>Amidst<note anchored="true" type="sum" resp="ed" place="unspecified">Pontius Rejects the Sham Surrender.</note> this blaze of angry
							excitement and thirst for vengeance, a levy was made and nearly all
							re-enlisted as volunteers. Nine legions were formed out of the former
							troops, and the army marched to Caudium. </p></div><div n="7" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> The fetials went on in advance, and on arriving at the city gate they
							ordered the garment to be stripped off from those who had made the
							capitulation and their arms to be tied behind their backs. </p></div><div n="8" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> As the apparitor, out of respect for Postumius' rank, was binding his
							cords loosely, “Why do you not,” he asked, “draw
							the cord tight that the surrender may be made in due form?” When
							they had entered the council chamber and reached the tribunal where
							Pontius was seated, the fetial addressed him thus: </p></div><div n="9" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> “Forasmuch as these men have, without being ordered thereto by
							the Roman people, the Quirites, given their promise and oath that a
							treaty shall be concluded and have thereby been guilty of high crime and
							misdemeanour, I do herewith make surrender to you of these men, to the
							end that the Roman people may he absolved from the guilt of a heinous
							and detestable act.” </p></div><div n="10" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> As the fetial said this Postumius struck him as hard as he could with
							his knee, and in a loud voice declared that he was a Samnite citizen,
							that he had violated the law of nations in maltreating the fetial who,
							as herald, was inviolable, and that after this the Romans would be all
							the more justified in prosecuting the war.<note anchored="true" n="5" resp="ed" place="unspecified"> “It is hard to say whether
								this trickery, at once so base and so foolish, should be ascribed to
								mere hypocrisy or to fanaticism; for the fanatic is as prone to
								falsehood as to cruelty, and justifies to himself the one no less
								than the other by holding that the end sanctifies the means. Yet it
								is a fanaticism less wicked indeed, but even more extraordinary,
								when a man like Livy can describe such a scene, and can represent,
								as he has done, the conduct of Pontius in such strong contrast with
								that of the Romans, without appearing to feel any admiration of the
								one or any shame for theother.” (<bibl>Arnold, History of
									Rome, II. p. 225</bibl>.) Most English readers will sympathise
								with Dr. Arnold here; few probably will read without a sense of pain
								Dr. Mommsen's defence of the part the Romans played in this
								transaction (pp. 364-5, Vol. I.). The proposition he lays down that
								“a great nation does not surrender what it possesses except
								under the pressure of extreme necessity: all treaties making
								concessions are acknowledgments of such a necessity, not moral
								obligations” is undoubtedly true from the Roman standpoint,
								but surely is subversive of any ehtical basis on which international
								amity can rest to-day.</note>
						            </p></div></div><div n="11" subtype="chapter" type="textpart"><div n="1" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p>Pontius replied:“I shall not accept this surrender of yours nor
							will the Samnites regard it as valid. </p></div><div n="2" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Why do you not, Spurius Postumius, if you believe in the existence of
							gods, either cancel the whole agreement or abide by what you have
							pledged yourself to. The Samnite people have a right to all those whom
							it held in its power, or in their stead it has a right to make peace
							with Rome. </p></div><div n="3" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> But why do I appeal to you? You are keeping your word as far as you can
							and rendering yourself as prisoner to your conqueror. I appeal to the
							Roman people. If they are dissatisfied with the convention of the
							Caudine Forks, let them place their legions once more between the passes
							which imprisoned them. </p></div><div n="4" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Let there be no fraudulent dealing on either side, let the whole
							transaction be annuled, let them resume the arms which they delivered up
							at the capitulation, let them return to that camp of theirs, let them
							have everything that they had on the eve of their surrender. When that
							is done, then let them take a bold line and vote for war, then let the
							convention and the peace agreed to be repudiated. </p></div><div n="5" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Let us carry on the war with the same fortune and on the same ground
							which we held before any mention was made of peace; the Roman people
							will not then have any occasion to blame their consuls for pledges they
							had no right to give, nor shall we have any reason to charge the Roman
							people with any breach of faith.” </p></div><div n="6" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> “Will you never be at a loss for reasons why, after defeat, you
							should not abide by your agreements? You gave hostages to Porsena,
							afterwards you stole them away. </p></div><div n="7" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> You ransomed your city from the Gauls with gold, whilst they were in the
							act of receiving the gold they were cut down. You made peace with us on
							condition of our restoring your captured legions, you are now making
							that peace null and void. </p></div><div n="8" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> You always cloak your dishonest dealing under some specious pretext of
							right and justice. Does the Roman people not approve of its legion being
							saved at the cost of a humiliating peace? Then let it keep its peace to
							itself, only let it restore to the victor its captured legions. </p></div><div n="9" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Such action would be in accord with the dictates of honour, with the
							faith of treaties, with the solemn proceedings of the fetials. But that
							you should secure what you stipulated for, the safety of thousands of
							your countrymen, whilst I am not to secure the peace which I stipulated
							for when I released them —is this what you Aulus Cornelius and you
							fetials call acting according to the law of nations?” </p></div><div n="10" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> “As to those men whom you make believe to surrender I neither
							accept them nor do I regard them as surrendered, nor do I hinder them
							from returning to their countrymen, who are bound by a convention, the
							violation of which brings down the wrath of all the gods whose majesty
							is being trifled with. </p></div><div n="11" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> True, Spurius Postumius has just struck the herald fetial with his knee,
							then wage war! Of course the gods will believe that Postumius is a
							Samnite citizen not a Roman, and that it is by a Samnite citizen that a
							Roman herald has been maltreated, and that for that reason you are
							justified in making war upon us. </p></div><div n="12" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> It is sad to think that you feel no shame in exposing this mockery of
							religion to the light of day, and that old men of consular rank should
							invent excuses for breaking their word which even children would think
							beneath them. </p></div><div n="13" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Go, lictor, remove the bonds from the Romans, let none of them be
							hindered from departing where they please.” Thus set free they
							returned to the Roman camp, their personal obligations and possibly
							those of the State having been discharged. </p></div></div><div n="12" subtype="chapter" type="textpart"><div n="1" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p>The<note anchored="true" type="sum" resp="ed" place="unspecified">Renewal
								of the War.</note> Samnites clearly saw that instead of the peace
							which they had so arrogantly dictated, a most bitter war had commenced.
							They not only had a foreboding of all that was coming but they almost
							saw it with their eyes; now when it was too late they began to view with
							approval the two alternatives which the elder Pontius had suggested.
						</p></div><div n="2" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> They saw that they had fallen between the two, and by adopting a middle
							course had exchanged the secure possession of victory for an insecure
							and doubtful peace. </p></div><div n="3" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> They realised that they had lost the chance of doing either a kindness
							or an injury, and would have to fight with those whom they might have
							got rid of for ever as enemies or secured for ever as friends. And
							though no battle had yet given either side the advantage, men's feelings
							had so changed that Postumius enjoyed a </p></div><div n="4" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> greater reputation amongst the Romans for his surrender than Pontius
							possessed amongst the Samnites for his bloodless victory. </p></div><div n="5" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> The Roman regarded the possibility of war as involving the certainty of
							victory, whilst the Samnites looked upon the renewal of hostilities by
							the Roman as equivalent to their own defeat. In the meantime, Satricum
							revolted to the Samnites. The latter made a sudden descent on Fregellae
							and succeeded in occupying it in the night, assisted, there is no doubt
							by the Satricans. </p></div><div n="6" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Mutual fear kept both the Samnites and the Fregellans quiet till
							daylight, with the return of light the battle began. For some time the
							Fregellans held their ground, for they were fighting for their hearths
							and homes and the noncombatant population assisted them from the roofs
							of the houses. </p></div><div n="7" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> At length the assailants gained the advantage by adopting a ruse. A
							proclamation was made that all who laid down their arms should depart
							unhurt, and the defenders did not interfere with the crier who made it
							Now that there were hopes of safety they fought with less energy and in
							all directions arms were thrown away. </p></div><div n="8" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Some, however, showed more determination and made their way fully armed
							through the opposite gate. Their courage proved a better protection than
							the timid credulity of the others, for these were hemmed in by the
							Samnites with a ring of fire, and in spite of their cries for mercy were
							burnt to death.. </p></div><div n="9" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p>After arranging their respective commands, the consuls took the field.
							Papirius marched into Apulia as far as Luceria, where the equites who
							had been given as hostages at Caudium were interned; Publilius remained
							in Samnium to oppose the legions who had been at Caudium. </p></div><div n="10" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> His presence made the Samnites uncertain how to act; they could not
							march to Luceria for fear of exposing themselves to a rear attack, nor
							did they feel satisfied to remain where they were, as Luceria might in
							the meantime he lost. </p></div><div n="11" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> They decided that the best course would be to try their fortune and
							hazard a battle with Publilius. </p></div></div><div n="13" subtype="chapter" type="textpart"><div n="1" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p>Accordingly they drew up their forces for action. Before engaging them
							Publilius thought he ought to address a few words to his men, and
							ordered the Assembly to be sounded. There was such an eager rush,
							however, to the general's tent, and such loud shouts were raised in all
							directions as the men clamoured to be led to battle, that none of the
							general's address was heard; the memory of their recent disgrace was
							quite enough of itself to stimulate every man to fight. </p></div><div n="2" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> They strode rapidly into battle, urging the standard-bearers to move
							faster, and, to avoid any delay in having to hurl their javelins, they
							flung them away as if at a given signal and rushed upon the enemy with
							naked steel. </p></div><div n="3" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> There was no time for the commander's skill to be shown in manoeuvring
							his men or posting his reserves, it was all carried through by the
							enraged soldiers, who charged like madmen. </p></div><div n="4" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> The enemy were not only routed, they did not even venture to stay their
							flight at their camp, but went in scattered parties in the direction of
							Apulia. Eventually they rallied and reached Luceria in a body. </p></div><div n="5" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> The same rage and fury which had carried the Romans through the midst of
							the enemy hurried them on to the Samnite camp, and more carnage took
							place there than on the battle-field. Most of the plunder was destroyed
							in their excitement. The other army under Papirius had marched along the
							coast and reached Arpi. </p></div><div n="6" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> The whole of the country through which he passed was peaceably disposed,
							an attitude which was due more to the injuries inflicted by the Samnites
							than to any services which the Romans had rendered. </p></div><div n="7" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> For the Samnites used to live at that day in open hamlets among the
							mountains, and they were in the habit of making marauding incursions
							into the low country and the coastal districts. Living the free open-air
							life of mountaineers, themselves they despised the less hardy
							cultivators of the plains who, as often happens, had developed a
							character in harmony with their surroundings. </p></div><div n="8" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> If this tract of country had been on good terms with the Samnites, the
							Roman army would either have failed to reach Arpi or they would have
							been unable to obtain provisions on their route, and so would have been
							cut off from supplies of every kind. </p></div><div n="9" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Even as it was, when they had advanced to Luceria both besieged and
							besiegers were suffering from scarcity of provisions. The Romans drew
							all their supplies from Arpi but in very small quantities, for, as the
							infantry were all employed in outpost and patrol duty and in the
							construction of the </p></div><div n="10" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> siege-works, the cavalry brought the corn from Arpi in their haversacks,
							and sometimes when they encountered the enemy they were compelled to
							throw these away so as to be free to fight. The besieged, on the other
							hand, were obtaining their provisions and reinforcements from Samnium.
						</p></div><div n="11" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> But the arrival of the other consul, Publilius, with his victorious army
							led to their being more closely invested. He left the conduct of the
							siege to his colleague that he might be free to intercept the enemy's
							convoys on all sides. </p></div><div n="12" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> When the Samnites, who were encamped before Luceria, found that there
							was no hope of the besieged enduring their privations any longer, they
							were compelled to concentrate their whole strength and offer battle to
							Papirius. </p></div></div><div n="14" subtype="chapter" type="textpart"><div n="1" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p>Whilst both sides were making their preparations for battle, a deputation
							from Tarentum appeared on the scene with a peremptory demand that both
							the Samnites and the Romans should desist from hostilities. They
							threatened that whichever side stood in the way of a cessation of arms,
							they would assist the other side against them. </p></div><div n="2" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> After hearing the demands which the deputation advanced and apparently
							attaching importance to what they had said, Papirius replied that he
							would communicate with his colleague. He then sent for him and employed
							the interval in hastening the preparations for battle. After talking
							over the matter, about which there could be no two opinions, he
							displayed the signal for battle. </p></div><div n="3" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Whilst the consuls were engaged in the various duties, religious and
							otherwise, which are customary before a battle, the Tarentines waited
							for them, expecting an answer, and Papirius informed them that the
							pullarius had reported that the auspices were favourable and the
							sacrifice most satisfactory. </p></div><div n="4" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> “You see,” he added, “that we are going into action
							with the sanction of the gods.” </p></div><div n="5" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> He then ordered the standards to be taken up, and as he marched his men
							on to the field he expressed his contempt for a people of such egregious
							vanity, that whilst quite incapable of managing their own affairs, owing
							to domestic strife and discord, they thought themselves justified in
							prescribing to others how far they must go in making peace or war. </p></div><div n="6" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p>The Samnites, on the other hand, had given up all thoughts of fighting,
							either because they were really anxious for peace or because it was
							their interest to appear so, in order to secure the goodwill of the
							Tarentines. </p></div><div n="7" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> When they suddenly caught sight of the Romans drawn up for battle, they
							shouted that they should act according to the instructions of the
							Tarentines; they would neither go down into the field nor carry their
							arms outside their rampart, they would rather let advantage be taken of
							them and bear whatever chance might bring them than be </p></div><div n="8" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> thought to have flouted the peaceful advice of Tarentum The consuls said
							that they welcomed the omen, and prayed that the enemy might remain in
							that mood so as not even to defend their rampart. </p></div><div n="9" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Advancing in two divisions up to the entrenchments, they attacked them
							simultaneously on all sides. Some began to fill up the fosse, others
							tore down the abattis on the rampart and hurled the timber into the
							fosse. It was not their native courage only, but indignation and rage as
							well which goaded them On smarting as they were from their recent
							disgrace. </p></div><div n="10" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> As they forced their way into the camp, they reminded one another that
							there were no Forks of Caudium there, none of those insuperable defiles
							where deceit had won an insolent victory over incaution, but Roman
							valour which neither rampart nor fosse could check. They slew alike
							those who fought and those who fled, armed and unarmed, slaves and
							freemen, young and old, men and beasts. </p></div><div n="11" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Not a single living thing would have survived had not the </p></div><div n="12" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> consuls given the signal to retire, and by stern commands and threats
							driven the soldiers who were thirsting for blood out of the enemy's
							camp. </p></div><div n="13" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> As the men were highly incensed at this interruption to a vengeance
							which was so delightful, it was necessary to explain to them on the spot
							why they were prevented from carrying it further. </p></div><div n="14" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> The consuls assured them that they neither had yielded nor would yield
							to any man in showing their hatred of the enemy, and as they had been
							their leaders in the fighting so they would have been foremost in
							encouraging their insatiable rage and vengeance. </p></div><div n="15" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> But they had to consider the 6oo equites who were being detained as
							hostages in Luceria, and to take care that the enemy, despairing of any
							quarter for themselves, did not wreak their blind rage on their
							captives, and destroy them before they perished themselves. </p></div><div n="16" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> The soldiers quite approved and were glad that their indiscriminate fury
							had been checked; they admitted that they must submit to anything rather
							than endanger the safety of so many youths belonging to the noblest
							families in Rome. </p></div></div><div n="15" subtype="chapter" type="textpart"><div n="1" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p>The soldiers were dismissed to quarters, and a council of war was held to
							decide whether they should press on the siege of Luceria with their
							whole force or whether Publilius with his army should visit the Apulians
							and ascertain their intentions, about which there was considerable
							doubt. </p></div><div n="2" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> The latter was decided upon, and the consul succeeded in reducing a
							considerable number of their towns in one campaign, whilst others were
							admitted into alliance. </p></div><div n="3" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p>Papirius, who had remained behind to prosecute the siege of Luceria, soon
							found his expectations realised, for as all the roads by which supplies
							could be brought in were blocked, the Samnite garrison in Luceria was so
							reduced by famine that they sent to the Roman consul an offer to restore
							the hostages, for whose recovery the war had been undertaken, if he
							would raise the siege. </p></div><div n="4" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> He replied that they ought to have consulted Pontius, at whose
							instigation they had sent the Romans under the yoke, as to what terms he
							thought ought to he imposed on the vanquished. </p></div><div n="5" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> As, however, they preferred that equal terms should be fixed by the
							enemy rather than proposed by themselves, he told the negotiators to
							take back word to Luceria that all the arms, baggage, and beasts of
							burden together with the non-combatant population were to be left
							behind; the soldiers he should send under the yoke and leave them one
							garment apiece. </p></div><div n="6" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> In doing this, he said, he was subjecting them to no novel disgrace but
							simply retaliating upon them one which they had themselves inflicted.
						</p></div><div n="7" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> They were compelled to accept these terms and 7000 men were sent under
							the yoke. An enormous amount of booty was found in Luceria, all the arms
							and standards which had been taken at Caudium, and what created the
							greatest joy of all —they recovered the equites, the hostages whom the
							Samnites had placed there for security. </p></div><div n="8" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Hardly any victory that Rome ever won was more noteworthy for the sudden
							change that it wrought in the circumstances of the republic, especially
							if, as I find stated in some annals, Pontius, the son of Herennius, the
							Samnite captain-general, was sent under the yoke with the rest, to
							expiate the disgrace he had inflicted on the consul. </p></div><div n="9" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> I am not, however, so much surprised that uncertainty should exist with
							regard to this point as I am that any doubt should be felt as to who
							really captured Luceria; </p></div><div n="10" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> whether, that is to say, it was Lucius Cornelius, acting as Dictator,
							with L. Papirius Cursor as Master of the Horse, who achieved those
							successes at Caudium and afterwards at Luceria, and as the one man who
							avenged the stain on Roman honour celebrated what I am inclined to think
							was, with the exception of that of F. Camillus, the most justly earned
							triumph that any down to that day had enjoyed, or whether the glory of
							that distinction should be attributed to the consuls and especially to
							Papirius. </p></div><div n="11" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> There is a further mistake here owing to doubts as to whether at the
							next consular elections Papirius Cursor was re-elected for the third
							time in consequence of his success at Luceria, together with Q. Aulius
							Corretanus for the second time, or whether the name should really be L.
							Papirius Mugilanus. </p></div></div><div n="16" subtype="chapter" type="textpart"><div n="1" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p>The<note anchored="true" type="sum" resp="ed" place="unspecified">Reduction of Satricum.</note> authorities are agreed that the
							remainder of the war was conducted by the consuls. Aulius finished the
							campaign against the Frentanians in one battle. Their routed army fled
							to their city, and after giving hostages the consul received their
							surrender. </p></div><div n="2" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p>The other consul was equally fortunate in his campaign against the
							Satricans. Though admitted to Roman citizenship they had revolted to the
							Samnites after the Caudine disaster and allowed them to garrison their
							city. </p></div><div n="3" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> But when the Roman army was close to their walls they sent an urgent
							request, couched in very humble terms, for peace. The consul replied
							that unless they handed over the Samnite garrison or put them to death
							they were not to go to him again. The severity of this reply created
							more terror amongst them than the actual presence of the Roman army.
						</p></div><div n="4" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> They repeatedly asked him by what means he thought that such a small and
							weak body as they were could attempt to use force against a strong and
							well-armed garrison. He told them to seek counsel from those through
							whose advice they had admitted the garrison in the first instance. After
							having with some difficulty obtained his permission to consult their
							senate, they returned to the city. </p></div><div n="5" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> There were two parties in the senate: the leaders of the one were the
							authors of the revolt from Rome, the other consisted of loyal citizens.
						</p></div><div n="6" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Both, however, were equally anxious that every effort should be made to
							induce the consul to grant peace. As the Samnite garrison were not in
							the least prepared to stand a siege, they intended to evacuate the city
							the following night. </p></div><div n="7" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> The party who had introduced them thought it would be quite sufficient
							to let the consul know at what hour and by what gate they would leave;
							the others who had been all along opposed to their coming actually
							opened the gate to the consul that very night and admitted his troops
							into the city. </p></div><div n="8" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> The Samnites were unexpectedly attacked by a force concealed in the
							woods through which they were marching whilst the shouts of the Roman
							were resounding in all parts of the city; by this double act of
							treachery the Samnites were slain and Satricum captured within the space
							of one short hour and the consul became complete master of the
							situation. </p></div><div n="9" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> He ordered a strict inquiry to be made as to who were responsible for
							the revolt, and those who were found to be guilty were scourged and
							beheaded. </p></div><div n="10" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> The Satricans were deprived of their arms and a strong garrison was
							placed in the city. The writers who tell us that it was under Papirius
							that Luceria was recovered and the Samnites sent under the yoke, </p></div><div n="11" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> go on to inform us that after the capture of Satricum he returned to
							Rome to celebrate his triumph. </p></div><div n="12" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> And indeed he was, undoubtedly, a man deserving of all praise for his
							soldierly qualities, distinguished as he was not only by intellectual
							force but also by his physical prowess. </p></div><div n="13" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> He was especially noted for his swiftness of foot, which gave him his
								cognomen<note anchored="true" n="6" resp="ed" place="unspecified">
								“Cursor"="the runner.” </note>; he is stated to have
							beaten all those of his own age in racing. Owing either to his great
							strength or the amount of exercise he took he had an enormous appetite.
						</p></div><div n="14" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Under no commander did either horse or foot find service harder, for he
							himself never knew what it was to be tired. On one occasion the cavalry
							ventured to ask him to excuse them some of their fatigue duty in
							consideration of their having fought a successful action. </p></div><div n="15" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> He replied: “That you may not say I never excuse you anything, I
							excuse you from rubbing your horses' backs when you dismount.”
						</p></div><div n="16" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> He was as much of a martinet to the allies of Rome as he was to his own
							countrymen. </p></div><div n="17" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> The commander of the Praenestine detachment had shown a lack of courage
							in bringing his men up from the rear into the fighting line . Papirius,
							walking in front of his tent, ordered him to be called up, and on his
							appearance told the lictor to get the axe ready. The Praenestine, on
							hearing this, stood paralysed with fear. </p></div><div n="18" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> “Come, lictor,” said Papirius, “cut out this root;
							it is in the way of people as they walk.” After almost
							frightening him to death with this threat, he dismissed him with a fine.
						</p></div><div n="19" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> No age has been more prolific in great and noble characters than the one
							in which he lived, and even in that age there was no one whose single
							arm did more to sustain the commonwealth. Had Alexander the Great, after
							subjugating Asia, turned his attention to Europe, there are many who
							maintain that he would have met his match in Papirius. </p></div></div><div n="17" subtype="chapter" type="textpart"><div n="1" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p>Nothing<note anchored="true" type="sum" resp="ed" place="unspecified">Comparison of the Strength of Rome with that of Macedonia under
								Alexander the Great.</note> can he thought to be further from my aim
							since I commenced this task than to digress more than is necessary from
							the order of the narrative or by embellishing my work with a variety of
							topics to afford pleasant resting-places, as it were, for my readers and
							mental relaxation for myself. </p></div><div n="2" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> The mention, however, of so great a king and commander induces me to lay
							before my readers some reflections which I have often made when I have
							proposed to myself the question, “What would have been the
							results for Rome if she had been engaged in war with Alexander?”
						</p></div><div n="3" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> The things which tell most in war are the numbers and courage of the
							troops, the ability of the commanders, and Fortune, who has such a
							potent influence over human affairs, especially those of war. </p></div><div n="4" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Any one who considers these factors either separately or in combination
							will easily see that as the Roman empire proved invincible against other
							kings and nations, so it would have proved invincible against Alexander.
						</p></div><div n="5" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p>Let us, first of all, compare the commanders on each side. I do not
							dispute that Alexander was an exceptional general, but his reputation is
							enhanced by the fact that he died while still young and before he had
							time to experience any change of fortune. </p></div><div n="6" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Not to mention other kings and illustrious captains, who afford striking
							examples of the mutability of human affairs, I will only instance Cyrus,
							whom the Greeks celebrate as one of the greatest of men. What was it
							that exposed him to reverses and misfortunes but the length of his life,
							as recently in the case of Pompey the Great? </p></div><div n="7" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Let me enumerate the Roman generals —not all out of all ages but only
							those with whom as consuls and Dictators Alexander would have had to
							fight — </p></div><div n="8" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> M. Valerius Corvus, C. Marcius Rutilus, C. Sulpicius, T. Manlius
							Torquatus, Q. Publilius Philo, L. Papirius Cursor, Q. Fabius Maximus,
							the two Decii, L. Volumnius, and Manlius Curius. Following these come
							those men of colossal mould who would have confronted him if he had
							first turned his arms against Carthage and then crossed over into Italy
							later in life. </p></div><div n="9" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Every one of these men was Alexander's equal in courage and ability, and
							the </p></div><div n="10" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> art of war, which from the beginning of the City had been an unbroken
							tradition, had now grown into a science based on definite and permanent
							rules. It was thus that the kings conducted their wars, and alter them
							the Junii and the Valerii, who expelled the kings, and in later
							succession the Fabii, the Quinctii, and the Cornelii. </p></div><div n="11" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> It was these rules that Camillus followed, and the men who would have
							had to fight with Alexander had seen Camillus as an old man when they
							were little more than boys. Alexander no doubt did all that a soldier
							ought to do in battle, and that is not his least title to fame. </p></div><div n="12" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> But if Manlius Torquatus had been opposed to him in the field, would he
							have been inferior to him in this respect, or Valerius Corvus, both of
							them distinguished as soldiers before they assumed command? </p></div><div n="13" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Would the Decii, who, after devoting themselves, rushed upon the enemy,
							or Papirius Cursor with his vast physical courage and strength? </p></div><div n="14" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Would the clever generalship of one young man have succeeded in baffling
							the whole senate, not to mention individuals, that senate of which he,
							who declared that it was composed of kings, alone formed a true idea?
						</p></div><div n="15" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Was there any danger of his showing more skill than any of those whom I
							have mentioned in choosing the site for his camp, or organising his
							commissariat, or guarding against surprises, or choosing the right
							moment for giving battle, or disposing his men in line of battle and
							posting his reserves to the best advantage? </p></div><div n="16" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> He would have said that it was not with Darius that he had to do,
							dragging after him a train of women and eunuchs, wrapped up in purple
							and gold, encumbered with all the trappings of state, He found him an
							easy prey rather than a formidable enemy and defeated him without loss,
							without being called to do anything more daring than to show a just
							contempt for the idle show of power. </p></div><div n="17" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> The aspect of Italy would have struck him as very different from the
							India which he traversed in drunken revelry with an intoxicated army; he
							would have seen in the passes of Apulia and the mountains of Lucania the
							traces of the recent disaster which befell his house when his uncle
							Alexander, King of Epirus, perished. </p></div></div></div></div></body></text></TEI>
                </passage>
            </reply>
            </GetPassage>