<GetPassage xmlns:tei="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0" xmlns="http://chs.harvard.edu/xmlns/cts">
            <request>
                <requestName>GetPassage</requestName>
                <requestUrn>urn:cts:latinLit:phi0914.phi001.perseus-eng3:9.10-9.13</requestUrn>
            </request>
            <reply>
                <urn>urn:cts:latinLit:phi0914.phi001.perseus-eng3:9.10-9.13</urn>
                <passage>
                    <TEI xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><text><body><div n="urn:cts:latinLit:phi0914.phi001.perseus-eng3" type="edition" xml:lang="eng"><div n="9" subtype="book" type="textpart"><div n="10" subtype="chapter" type="textpart"><div n="1" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p>Both<note anchored="true" type="sum" resp="ed" place="unspecified">Postumius' Advice taken.</note> the speech and the speaker produced
							a great impression on all who heard him, including the tribunes, who
							were so far influenced by what they had heard that they formally placed
							themselves at the disposal of the senate. </p></div><div n="2" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> They immediately resigned their office and were handed over to the
							fetials to be conducted with the rest to Caudium. After the senate had
							passed their resolution, it seemed as though the light of day was once
							more shining on the State. </p></div><div n="3" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> The name of Postumius was in all men's mouths, he was extolled to the
							skies, his conduct was put on a level with the selfsacrifice of P.
							Decius and other splendid deeds of heroism. </p></div><div n="4" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> It was through his counsel and assistance, men said, that the State had
							found its way out of a dishonourable and guilty peace; he was exposing
							himself to the rage of the enemy and all the tortures they could inflict
							as an expiatory victim for the Roman people. </p></div><div n="5" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> All eyes were turned to arms and war; “shall we ever be
							allowed,” they exclaimed, “to meet the Samnites in
							arms?” </p></div><div n="6" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p>Amidst<note anchored="true" type="sum" resp="ed" place="unspecified">Pontius Rejects the Sham Surrender.</note> this blaze of angry
							excitement and thirst for vengeance, a levy was made and nearly all
							re-enlisted as volunteers. Nine legions were formed out of the former
							troops, and the army marched to Caudium. </p></div><div n="7" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> The fetials went on in advance, and on arriving at the city gate they
							ordered the garment to be stripped off from those who had made the
							capitulation and their arms to be tied behind their backs. </p></div><div n="8" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> As the apparitor, out of respect for Postumius' rank, was binding his
							cords loosely, “Why do you not,” he asked, “draw
							the cord tight that the surrender may be made in due form?” When
							they had entered the council chamber and reached the tribunal where
							Pontius was seated, the fetial addressed him thus: </p></div><div n="9" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> “Forasmuch as these men have, without being ordered thereto by
							the Roman people, the Quirites, given their promise and oath that a
							treaty shall be concluded and have thereby been guilty of high crime and
							misdemeanour, I do herewith make surrender to you of these men, to the
							end that the Roman people may he absolved from the guilt of a heinous
							and detestable act.” </p></div><div n="10" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> As the fetial said this Postumius struck him as hard as he could with
							his knee, and in a loud voice declared that he was a Samnite citizen,
							that he had violated the law of nations in maltreating the fetial who,
							as herald, was inviolable, and that after this the Romans would be all
							the more justified in prosecuting the war.<note anchored="true" n="5" resp="ed" place="unspecified"> “It is hard to say whether
								this trickery, at once so base and so foolish, should be ascribed to
								mere hypocrisy or to fanaticism; for the fanatic is as prone to
								falsehood as to cruelty, and justifies to himself the one no less
								than the other by holding that the end sanctifies the means. Yet it
								is a fanaticism less wicked indeed, but even more extraordinary,
								when a man like Livy can describe such a scene, and can represent,
								as he has done, the conduct of Pontius in such strong contrast with
								that of the Romans, without appearing to feel any admiration of the
								one or any shame for theother.” (<bibl>Arnold, History of
									Rome, II. p. 225</bibl>.) Most English readers will sympathise
								with Dr. Arnold here; few probably will read without a sense of pain
								Dr. Mommsen's defence of the part the Romans played in this
								transaction (pp. 364-5, Vol. I.). The proposition he lays down that
								“a great nation does not surrender what it possesses except
								under the pressure of extreme necessity: all treaties making
								concessions are acknowledgments of such a necessity, not moral
								obligations” is undoubtedly true from the Roman standpoint,
								but surely is subversive of any ehtical basis on which international
								amity can rest to-day.</note>
						            </p></div></div><div n="11" subtype="chapter" type="textpart"><div n="1" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p>Pontius replied:“I shall not accept this surrender of yours nor
							will the Samnites regard it as valid. </p></div><div n="2" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Why do you not, Spurius Postumius, if you believe in the existence of
							gods, either cancel the whole agreement or abide by what you have
							pledged yourself to. The Samnite people have a right to all those whom
							it held in its power, or in their stead it has a right to make peace
							with Rome. </p></div><div n="3" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> But why do I appeal to you? You are keeping your word as far as you can
							and rendering yourself as prisoner to your conqueror. I appeal to the
							Roman people. If they are dissatisfied with the convention of the
							Caudine Forks, let them place their legions once more between the passes
							which imprisoned them. </p></div><div n="4" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Let there be no fraudulent dealing on either side, let the whole
							transaction be annuled, let them resume the arms which they delivered up
							at the capitulation, let them return to that camp of theirs, let them
							have everything that they had on the eve of their surrender. When that
							is done, then let them take a bold line and vote for war, then let the
							convention and the peace agreed to be repudiated. </p></div><div n="5" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Let us carry on the war with the same fortune and on the same ground
							which we held before any mention was made of peace; the Roman people
							will not then have any occasion to blame their consuls for pledges they
							had no right to give, nor shall we have any reason to charge the Roman
							people with any breach of faith.” </p></div><div n="6" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> “Will you never be at a loss for reasons why, after defeat, you
							should not abide by your agreements? You gave hostages to Porsena,
							afterwards you stole them away. </p></div><div n="7" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> You ransomed your city from the Gauls with gold, whilst they were in the
							act of receiving the gold they were cut down. You made peace with us on
							condition of our restoring your captured legions, you are now making
							that peace null and void. </p></div><div n="8" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> You always cloak your dishonest dealing under some specious pretext of
							right and justice. Does the Roman people not approve of its legion being
							saved at the cost of a humiliating peace? Then let it keep its peace to
							itself, only let it restore to the victor its captured legions. </p></div><div n="9" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Such action would be in accord with the dictates of honour, with the
							faith of treaties, with the solemn proceedings of the fetials. But that
							you should secure what you stipulated for, the safety of thousands of
							your countrymen, whilst I am not to secure the peace which I stipulated
							for when I released them —is this what you Aulus Cornelius and you
							fetials call acting according to the law of nations?” </p></div><div n="10" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> “As to those men whom you make believe to surrender I neither
							accept them nor do I regard them as surrendered, nor do I hinder them
							from returning to their countrymen, who are bound by a convention, the
							violation of which brings down the wrath of all the gods whose majesty
							is being trifled with. </p></div><div n="11" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> True, Spurius Postumius has just struck the herald fetial with his knee,
							then wage war! Of course the gods will believe that Postumius is a
							Samnite citizen not a Roman, and that it is by a Samnite citizen that a
							Roman herald has been maltreated, and that for that reason you are
							justified in making war upon us. </p></div><div n="12" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> It is sad to think that you feel no shame in exposing this mockery of
							religion to the light of day, and that old men of consular rank should
							invent excuses for breaking their word which even children would think
							beneath them. </p></div><div n="13" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Go, lictor, remove the bonds from the Romans, let none of them be
							hindered from departing where they please.” Thus set free they
							returned to the Roman camp, their personal obligations and possibly
							those of the State having been discharged. </p></div></div><div n="12" subtype="chapter" type="textpart"><div n="1" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p>The<note anchored="true" type="sum" resp="ed" place="unspecified">Renewal
								of the War.</note> Samnites clearly saw that instead of the peace
							which they had so arrogantly dictated, a most bitter war had commenced.
							They not only had a foreboding of all that was coming but they almost
							saw it with their eyes; now when it was too late they began to view with
							approval the two alternatives which the elder Pontius had suggested.
						</p></div><div n="2" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> They saw that they had fallen between the two, and by adopting a middle
							course had exchanged the secure possession of victory for an insecure
							and doubtful peace. </p></div><div n="3" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> They realised that they had lost the chance of doing either a kindness
							or an injury, and would have to fight with those whom they might have
							got rid of for ever as enemies or secured for ever as friends. And
							though no battle had yet given either side the advantage, men's feelings
							had so changed that Postumius enjoyed a </p></div><div n="4" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> greater reputation amongst the Romans for his surrender than Pontius
							possessed amongst the Samnites for his bloodless victory. </p></div><div n="5" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> The Roman regarded the possibility of war as involving the certainty of
							victory, whilst the Samnites looked upon the renewal of hostilities by
							the Roman as equivalent to their own defeat. In the meantime, Satricum
							revolted to the Samnites. The latter made a sudden descent on Fregellae
							and succeeded in occupying it in the night, assisted, there is no doubt
							by the Satricans. </p></div><div n="6" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Mutual fear kept both the Samnites and the Fregellans quiet till
							daylight, with the return of light the battle began. For some time the
							Fregellans held their ground, for they were fighting for their hearths
							and homes and the noncombatant population assisted them from the roofs
							of the houses. </p></div><div n="7" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> At length the assailants gained the advantage by adopting a ruse. A
							proclamation was made that all who laid down their arms should depart
							unhurt, and the defenders did not interfere with the crier who made it
							Now that there were hopes of safety they fought with less energy and in
							all directions arms were thrown away. </p></div><div n="8" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Some, however, showed more determination and made their way fully armed
							through the opposite gate. Their courage proved a better protection than
							the timid credulity of the others, for these were hemmed in by the
							Samnites with a ring of fire, and in spite of their cries for mercy were
							burnt to death.. </p></div><div n="9" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p>After arranging their respective commands, the consuls took the field.
							Papirius marched into Apulia as far as Luceria, where the equites who
							had been given as hostages at Caudium were interned; Publilius remained
							in Samnium to oppose the legions who had been at Caudium. </p></div><div n="10" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> His presence made the Samnites uncertain how to act; they could not
							march to Luceria for fear of exposing themselves to a rear attack, nor
							did they feel satisfied to remain where they were, as Luceria might in
							the meantime he lost. </p></div><div n="11" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> They decided that the best course would be to try their fortune and
							hazard a battle with Publilius. </p></div></div><div n="13" subtype="chapter" type="textpart"><div n="1" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p>Accordingly they drew up their forces for action. Before engaging them
							Publilius thought he ought to address a few words to his men, and
							ordered the Assembly to be sounded. There was such an eager rush,
							however, to the general's tent, and such loud shouts were raised in all
							directions as the men clamoured to be led to battle, that none of the
							general's address was heard; the memory of their recent disgrace was
							quite enough of itself to stimulate every man to fight. </p></div><div n="2" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> They strode rapidly into battle, urging the standard-bearers to move
							faster, and, to avoid any delay in having to hurl their javelins, they
							flung them away as if at a given signal and rushed upon the enemy with
							naked steel. </p></div><div n="3" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> There was no time for the commander's skill to be shown in manoeuvring
							his men or posting his reserves, it was all carried through by the
							enraged soldiers, who charged like madmen. </p></div><div n="4" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> The enemy were not only routed, they did not even venture to stay their
							flight at their camp, but went in scattered parties in the direction of
							Apulia. Eventually they rallied and reached Luceria in a body. </p></div><div n="5" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> The same rage and fury which had carried the Romans through the midst of
							the enemy hurried them on to the Samnite camp, and more carnage took
							place there than on the battle-field. Most of the plunder was destroyed
							in their excitement. The other army under Papirius had marched along the
							coast and reached Arpi. </p></div><div n="6" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> The whole of the country through which he passed was peaceably disposed,
							an attitude which was due more to the injuries inflicted by the Samnites
							than to any services which the Romans had rendered. </p></div><div n="7" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> For the Samnites used to live at that day in open hamlets among the
							mountains, and they were in the habit of making marauding incursions
							into the low country and the coastal districts. Living the free open-air
							life of mountaineers, themselves they despised the less hardy
							cultivators of the plains who, as often happens, had developed a
							character in harmony with their surroundings. </p></div><div n="8" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> If this tract of country had been on good terms with the Samnites, the
							Roman army would either have failed to reach Arpi or they would have
							been unable to obtain provisions on their route, and so would have been
							cut off from supplies of every kind. </p></div><div n="9" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Even as it was, when they had advanced to Luceria both besieged and
							besiegers were suffering from scarcity of provisions. The Romans drew
							all their supplies from Arpi but in very small quantities, for, as the
							infantry were all employed in outpost and patrol duty and in the
							construction of the </p></div><div n="10" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> siege-works, the cavalry brought the corn from Arpi in their haversacks,
							and sometimes when they encountered the enemy they were compelled to
							throw these away so as to be free to fight. The besieged, on the other
							hand, were obtaining their provisions and reinforcements from Samnium.
						</p></div><div n="11" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> But the arrival of the other consul, Publilius, with his victorious army
							led to their being more closely invested. He left the conduct of the
							siege to his colleague that he might be free to intercept the enemy's
							convoys on all sides. </p></div><div n="12" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> When the Samnites, who were encamped before Luceria, found that there
							was no hope of the besieged enduring their privations any longer, they
							were compelled to concentrate their whole strength and offer battle to
							Papirius. </p></div></div></div></div></body></text></TEI>
                </passage>
            </reply>
            </GetPassage>