<GetPassage xmlns:tei="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0" xmlns="http://chs.harvard.edu/xmlns/cts">
            <request>
                <requestName>GetPassage</requestName>
                <requestUrn>urn:cts:latinLit:phi0914.phi001.perseus-eng3:5.1-5.5</requestUrn>
            </request>
            <reply>
                <urn>urn:cts:latinLit:phi0914.phi001.perseus-eng3:5.1-5.5</urn>
                <passage>
                    <TEI xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><text><body><div n="urn:cts:latinLit:phi0914.phi001.perseus-eng3" type="edition" xml:lang="eng"><div n="5" subtype="book" type="textpart"><div n="1" subtype="chapter" type="textpart"><div n="1" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p>Whilst<note anchored="true" type="sum" resp="ed" place="unspecified">The
								Siege of Veii —Appius and the Plebeian Tribunes.</note> peace
							prevailed elsewhere, Rome and Veii were confronting each other in arms,
							animated by such fury and hatred that utter ruin clearly awaited the
							vanquished. Each elected their magistrates, but on totally different
						</p></div><div n="2" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> principles. The Romans increased the number of their consular tribunes
							to eight —a larger number than had ever been elected before. They were
							Manius Aemilius Mamercus —for the second time —L. Valerius Potitus —for
							the third time —Appius Claudius Crassus, M. Quinctilius Varus, L. Julius
							Julus, M. Postumius, M. Furius Camillus, and M. Postumius Albinus. The
							Veientines, on the other hand, tired of the annual canvassing for
							office, elected a </p></div><div n="3" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> king. This gave great offence to the Etruscan cantons, owing to their
							hatred of monarchy and their personal aversion to the one who was </p></div><div n="4" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> elected. He was already obnoxious to the nation through his pride of
							wealth and overbearing temper, for he had put a violent stop to the
							festival of the Games, the interruption of which is an act of </p></div><div n="5" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> impiety. His candidature for the priesthood<note anchored="true" n="1" resp="ed" place="unspecified"><emph>priesthood.</emph> A national priest was elected annually to
								organise the Games and other State solemnities.</note> had been
							unsuccessful, another being preferred by the vote of the twelve cantons,
							and in revenge he suddenly withdrew the performers, most of whom were
							his own slaves, in the middle of the </p></div><div n="6" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Games. The Etruscans as a nation were distinguished above all others by
							their devotion to religious observances, because they excelled in the
							knowledge and conduct of them, and they decided, in consequence, that no
							assistance should be given to the Veientines as long as they were under
							a </p></div><div n="7" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> king. The report of this decision was suppressed at Veii through fear of
							the king; he treated those who mentioned anything of the kind, not as
							authors of an idle tale, but as ringleaders of </p></div><div n="8" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> sedition. Although the Romans had received intelligence that there was
							no movement on the part of the Etruscans, still, as it </p></div><div n="9" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> was reported that the matter was being discussed in all their councils,
							they so constructed their lines as to present a double face, the one
							fronting Veii to prevent sorties from the city, the other looking
							towards Etruria to intercept any succour from that side. </p></div></div><div n="2" subtype="chapter" type="textpart"><div n="1" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p>As the Roman generals placed more reliance on a blockade than on an
							assault, they began to build huts for winter quarters, a novelty to the
							Roman soldier. Their plan was to keep up the war through the winter. The
							tribunes of the plebs had for a long time been unable to find any
							pretext for creating a revolt. </p></div><div n="2" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> When, however, news of this was brought to Rome, they dashed off to the
							Assembly and produced great excitement by declaring that this was the
							reason why it had been settled to pay the troops. They, the tribunes,
							had not been blind to the fact that this gift from their adversaries
							would prove to be tainted with poison. </p></div><div n="3" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> The liberties of the plebs had been bartered away, their able-bodied men
							had been permanently sent away, banished from the City and the State,
							without any regard to winter or indeed to any season of the year, or to
							the possibility of their visiting their homes or looking after their
							property. What did they think was the reason for this continuous
							campaigning? </p></div><div n="4" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> They would most assuredly find it to be nothing else but the fear that
							if a large body of these men, who formed the whole strength of the
							plebs, were present, it would be possible to discuss reforms in favour
							of the plebeians. Besides, they were suffering much more hardship and
							oppression than the Veientines, for these passed the winter under their
							own roofs in a city protected by its magnificent walls and the natural
							strength of its position, whilst the Romans, amidst labour and toil,
							buried in frost and snow, were roughing it patiently under their
							skin-covered tents, and could not lay aside their arms even in the
							season of winter, when there is a respite from all wars, whether by land
							or sea. </p></div><div n="5" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> This form of slavery, making military service perpetual, was never
							imposed either by the kings, or by the consuls who were so domineering
							before the institution of the tribuneship, or during the stern rule of
							the Dictator, or by the unscrupulous decemvirs —it was the consular
							tribunes who were exercising this regal despotism over the Roman plebs.
						</p></div><div n="6" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> What would these men have done had they been consuls or Dictators,
							seeing that they have made their proconsular authority, which is only a
							shadow of the other, so outrageously cruel? But the commons had got what
							they had deserved. </p></div><div n="7" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Amongst all the eight consular tribunes not a single plebeian had found
							a place. Hitherto, with their utmost efforts, the patricians had usually
							filled only three places at a time; now a team of eight were bent on
							maintaining their power. Even in such a crowd not a single plebeian
							could get a footing, to warn his colleagues, if he could do nothing
							else, that those who were serving as soldiers were free men, their own
							fellow-citizens, and not slaves, and that they ought to be brought back,
							at all events in the winter, to their houses and their homes, and during
							some part of the year visit their parents and wives and children, and
							exercise their rights as free citizens in electing the magistrates.
							Whilst indulging in declamations of this sort, they found an opponent
							who was quite a match for them in Appius Claudius. </p></div><div n="8" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> He had from early manhood taken his part in the contests with the plebs,
							and as stated above, had some years previously recommended the senate to
							break down the power of the tribunes by securing the intervention of
							their colleagues. He was not only a man of ready and versatile mind, but
							by this time an experienced debater. </p></div><div n="9" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> He delivered the following speech on this occasion: — “If,
							Quirites, there has ever been any doubt as to whether it was in your
							interest or their own that the tribunes have always been the advocates
							of sedition, I feel quite certain that this year all doubt has ceased to
							exist. Whilst I rejoice that an end has at last been put to a
							long-standing delusion, I congratulate you, and on your behalf the whole
							State, that its removal has been effected just at the time when your
							circumstances are most prosperous. </p></div><div n="10" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Is there any one who doubts that whatever wrongs you may have at any
							time suffered, they never annoyed and provoked the tribunes so much as
							the generous treatment of the plebs by the senate, in establishing the
							system of pay for the soldiers? </p></div><div n="11" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> What else do you suppose it was that they were afraid of at that time,
							and would today gladly upset, except the harmony of the two orders,
							which they look upon as most of all calculated to destroy their power?
							They are, really, like so many quack doctors looking for work, always
							anxious to find some diseased spot in the republic that there may be
							something which you can call them in to cure.” Then, turning to
							the tribunes, “Are you defending or attacking the plebs? Are you
							trying to injure the men on service or are you pleading their cause?
						</p></div><div n="12" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Or perhaps this is what you are saying, “Whatever the senate
							does, whether in the interest of the plebs or against them, we object
							to.” </p></div><div n="13" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Just as masters forbid strangers to hold any communication with their
							slaves, and think it right that they should abstain from showing them
							either kindness or unkindness, so you interdict the patricians from all
							dealings with the plebs, lest we should appeal to their feelings by our
							graciousness and generosity and secure their loyalty and obedience. How
							much more dutiful it would have been in you, if you had had a spark —I
							will not say of patriotism, but —of common humanity, to have viewed with
							favour, and as far as in you lay, to have fostered the kindly feelings
							of the patricians and the grateful goodwill of the plebeians! </p></div><div n="14" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> And if this harmony should prove to be lasting, who would not be bold
							enough to guarantee that this empire will in a short time be the
							greatest among the neighbouring States?” </p></div></div><div n="4" subtype="chapter" type="textpart"><div n="1" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> “I shall subsequently show not only the expediency but even the
							necessity of the policy which my colleagues have adopted of refusing to
							withdraw the army from Veii until their object was effected. </p></div><div n="2" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> For the present I prefer to speak of the actual conditions under which
							it is serving, and if I were speaking not before you only but in the
							camp as well, I think that what I say would appear just and fair in the
							judgment of the soldiers themselves. Even if no arguments presented
							themselves to my mind, I should find those of my opponents quite
							sufficient for my purpose. </p></div><div n="3" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> They were saying lately that pay ought not to be given to the soldiers
							because it never had been given. How then can they now profess
							indignation at those who have gained additional benefits being required
							to undergo additional exertion in proportion? Nowhere do we find labour
							without its reward, nor, as a rule, reward without some expenditure of
							labour. </p></div><div n="4" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Toil and pleasure, utterly dissimilar by nature, have been brought by
							nature into a kind of partnership with each other. </p></div><div n="5" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Formerly, the soldier felt it a grievance that he gave his services to
							the State at his own cost, he had the satisfaction, however, of
							cultivating his land for a part of the year, and acquiring the means of
							supporting himself and his family whether he were at home or on service.
						</p></div><div n="6" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Now he has the pleasure of knowing that the State is a source of income
							to him, and he is glad to receive his pay. Let him therefore take it
							patiently that he is a little longer absent from his home and his
							property, on which no heavy expense now falls. </p></div><div n="7" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> If the State were to call him to an exact reckoning, would it not be
							justified in saying, “You receive a year's pay, put in a year's
							work. Do you think it fair to receive a whole twelve-month's pay for six
							months' service?” </p></div><div n="8" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> It is with reluctance, Quirites, that I dwell on this topic, for it is
							those who employ mercenaries who ought to deal thus with them, but we
							want to deal with you as with fellow-citizens, and we think it only fair
							that you should deal with us as with your fatherland.”
							“Either the war ought not to have been undertaken, or </p></div><div n="9" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> it ought to be conducted as befits the dignity of Rome and brought to a
							close as soon as possible. </p></div><div n="10" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> It will certainly be brought to a close if we press on the siege, but
							not if we retire before we have fulfilled our hopes by the capture of
							Veii. Why, good heavens! if there were no other reason, the very
							discredit of the thing ought to inspire us with perseverance. </p></div><div n="11" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> A city was once besieged by the whole of Greece for ten years, for the
							sake of one woman, and at what a distance from home, how many lands and
							seas lay between! </p></div><div n="12" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Are we growing tired of keeping up a siege for one year, not twenty
							miles off, almost within sight of the City? I suppose you think the
							reason for the war is a trivial one, and we do not feel enough just
							resentment to urge us to persevere. </p></div><div n="13" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Seven times have they recommenced war against us; they have never
							loyally kept to the terms of peace; they have ravaged our fields a
							thousand times; they forced the Fidenates to revolt; </p></div><div n="14" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> they slew the colonists whom we settled there; they instigated the
							impious murder of our ambassadors in violation of the law of nations;
							they wanted to raise the whole of Etruria against us, and they are
							trying to do so today; when we sent ambassadors to demand satisfaction,
							they very nearly outraged them.” </p></div></div><div n="5" subtype="chapter" type="textpart"><div n="1" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> “Are these the men with whom war ought to be carried on in a
							half-hearted and dilatory fashion? If such just reasons for resentment
							have no force with us, do not the following considerations, I pray you,
							possess any weight? </p></div><div n="2" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> The city is hemmed in by immense siege-works which confine the enemy
							within his walls. He has not tilled his land, and what was tilled before
							has been devastated by war. </p></div><div n="3" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> If we bring our army back again, has anybody the slightest doubt that
							they will invade our territory not only from a thirst for revenge, but
							also through the sheer necessity they are under of plundering other
							people's property since they have lost their own? </p></div><div n="4" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> If we adopt your policy we do not postpone the war, we simply carry it
							within our own frontiers.” “Well, now, what about the
							soldiers in whom these worthy tribunes have suddenly become interested
							after vainly endeavouring to rob them of their pay; what about them?
						</p></div><div n="5" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> They have carried a rampart and a fosse —each requiring enormous labour
							—over all that extent of ground; they have built forts, few at first,
							but after the army was increased, very numerous; they have raised
							defences not only against the city, but also as a barrier against
							Etruria in case any succours came from there. </p></div><div n="6" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> What need to describe the towers, the <foreign xml:lang="lat">vineae</foreign>, the <foreign xml:lang="lat">testudines</foreign>, and
							the other engines used in storming cities? Now that so much labour has
							been spent and the work of investment at last completed, do you think
							that they ought to be abandoned in order that by next summer we may be
							again exhausted by the toil of constructing them all afresh? </p></div><div n="7" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> How much less trouble to defend the works already constructed, to press
							on and persevere, and so bring our cares and labours to an end! For
							assuredly the undertaking is not a lengthy one, if it is carried through
							by one continuous effort, if we do not by our own interruptions and
							stoppages delay the fulfilment of our hopes.” “I have been
							speaking of the work and the loss of time. </p></div><div n="8" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Now there are frequent meetings of the national council of Etruria to
							discuss the question of sending succours to Veii. Do these allow us to
							forget the danger we incur by prolonging the war? </p></div><div n="9" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> As matters now stand, they are angry, resentful, and say that they will
							not send any —Veii may be captured, as far as they are concerned. But
							who will guarantee that if the war is prolonged they will continue in
							the same mind? </p></div><div n="10" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> For if you give the Veientines a respite they will send a more numerous
							and influential embassy, and what now gives such displeasure to the
							Etruscans, namely, the election of a king, may after a time be annulled
							either by the unanimous act of the citizens in order to win the
							sympathies of Etruria, or by voluntary abdication on the part of the
							king himself, through his unwillingness to allow his </p></div><div n="11" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> crown to endanger the safety of his people.” “See how many
							disastrous consequences follow from the policy you recommend —the
							sacrifice of works constructed with so much trouble; the threatening
							devastation of our borders; </p></div><div n="12" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> a war with the whole of Etruria instead of one with Veii alone.”
							This, tribunes, is what your proposals amount to; very much, upon my
							word, as if any one were to tempt a sick person, who by submitting to
							strict treatment could speedily recover, to indulge in eating and
							drinking, and so lengthen his illness and perhaps make it incurable.
						</p></div></div></div></div></body></text></TEI>
                </passage>
            </reply>
            </GetPassage>