<GetPassage xmlns:tei="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0" xmlns="http://chs.harvard.edu/xmlns/cts">
            <request>
                <requestName>GetPassage</requestName>
                <requestUrn>urn:cts:latinLit:phi0914.phi001.perseus-eng3:4.3-4.6</requestUrn>
            </request>
            <reply>
                <urn>urn:cts:latinLit:phi0914.phi001.perseus-eng3:4.3-4.6</urn>
                <passage>
                    <TEI xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><text><body><div n="urn:cts:latinLit:phi0914.phi001.perseus-eng3" type="edition" xml:lang="eng"><div n="4" subtype="book" type="textpart"><div n="3" subtype="chapter" type="textpart"><div n="1" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p>At the very time when this was going on in the senate, Canuleius
							delivered the following speech in defence of his laws and in opposition
							to the consuls: </p></div><div n="2" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> “I fancy, Quirites, that I have often noticed in the past how
							greatly the patricians despise you, how unworthy they deem you to live
							in the same City, within the same walls, as they. </p></div><div n="3" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Now, however, it is perfectly obvious, seeing how bitter an opposition
							they have raised to our proposed laws. For what is our purpose in
							framing them except to remind them that we are their fellow-citizens,
							and though we do not possess the same power, we still inhabit the same
							country? </p></div><div n="4" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> In one of these laws we demand the right of intermarriage, a right
							usually granted to neighbours and foreigners-indeed we have granted
							citizenship, which is more than intermarriage, </p></div><div n="5" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> even to a conquered enemy-in the other we are bringing forward nothing
							new, but simply demanding back what belongs to the people and claiming
							that the Roman people should confer its honours on whom it will. </p></div><div n="6" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> What possible reason is there why they should embroil heaven and earth,
							why recently in the Senate-house I was on the point of being subjected
							to personal violence, why they declare they will not keep their hands
							off, and threaten to attack our inviolable authority? </p></div><div n="7" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Will this City be no longer able to stand, is our dominion at an end, if
							a free vote is allowed to the Roman people so that they may entrust the
							consulship to whomsoever they will, and no plebeian may be shut out from
							the hope of attaining the highest honour if only he be worthy of the
							highest honour? </p></div><div n="8" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Does the phrase “Let no plebeian be made consul” mean just
							the same as “No slave or freedman shall be consul”? Do you
							ever realise in what contempt you are living? They would rob you of your
							share in this daylight, if they could. </p></div><div n="9" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> They are indignant because you breathe and utter speech and wear the
							form of men. Why! Heaven forgive me, they actually say that it would be
							an act of impiety for a plebeian to be made consul! Though we are not
							allowed access to the “ <foreign xml:lang="lat">Fasti</foreign>
							” or the records of the pontiffs, do we not, pray, know what
							every stranger knows, that the consuls have simply taken the place of
							the kings, and possess no right or privilege which was not previously
							vested in the kings? </p></div><div n="10" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> I suppose you have never heard tell that Numa Pompilius, who was not
							only no patrician but not even a Roman citizen, was summoned from the
							land of the Sabines, and after being accepted by the people and
							confirmed by the senate, reigned as king of Rome? </p></div><div n="11" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Or that, after him, L. Tarquinius, who belonged to no Roman house, not
							even to an Italian one, being the son of Demaratus of Corinth, who had
							settled in Tarquinii, was made king while the sons of Ancus were still
							alive? </p></div><div n="12" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Or that, after him again, Servius Tullius, the illegitimate son of a
							female slave captured at Corniculum, gained the crown by sheer merit and
							ability? Why need I mention the Sabine Titus Tatius, with whom Romulus
							himself, the Father of the City, shared his throne? </p></div><div n="13" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> As long as no class of person in which conspicuous merit appeared was
							rejected, the Roman dominion grew. Are you then to regard a plebeian
							consul with disgust, when our ancestors showed no aversion to strangers
							as their kings? </p></div><div n="14" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Not even after the expulsion of the kings was the City closed to foreign
							merit. The Claudian house, at all events, who migrated from the Sabines,
							was received by us not only into citizenship, but even into the ranks of
							the patricians. </p></div><div n="15" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Shall a man who was an alien become a patrician and afterwards consul,
							and a Roman citizen, if he belongs to the plebs, be cut off from all
							hope of the consulship? </p></div><div n="16" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Do we believe that it is impossible for a plebeian to be brave and
							energetic and capable both in peace and war, or if there be such a man,
							are we not to allow him to touch the helm of the State; </p></div><div n="17" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> are we to have, by preference, consuls like the decemvirs, those vilest
							of mortals-who, nevertheless, were all patricians-rather than men who
							resemble the best of the kings, new men though they were?” </p></div></div><div n="4" subtype="chapter" type="textpart"><div n="1" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> “But, I may be told, no consul, since the expulsion of the kings,
							has ever been elected from the plebs. What then? Ought no innovation
							ever to be introduced; and because a thing has not yet been done-and in
							a new community there are many things which have not yet been done-
							ought they not to be done, even when they are advantageous? </p></div><div n="2" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> In the reign of Romulus there were no pontiffs, no college of augurs;
							they were created by Numa Pompilius. There was no census in the State,
							no register of the centuries and classes; it was made by Servius
							Tullius. </p></div><div n="3" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> There were never any consuls; when the kings had been expelled they were
							created. Neither the power nor the name of Dictator was in existence; it
							originated with the senate. There were no tribunes of the plebs, no
							aediles, no quaestors; it was decided that these offices should be
							created. Within the last ten years we appointed decemvirs to commit the
							laws to writing and then we abolished their office. </p></div><div n="4" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Who doubts that in a City built for all time and without any limits to
							its growth new authorities have to be established, new priesthoods,
							modifications in the rights and privileges of the houses as well as of
							individual citizens? </p></div><div n="5" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Was not this very prohibition of intermarriage between patricians and
							plebeians, which inflicts such serious injury on the commonwealth and
							such a gross injustice on the plebs, made by the decemvirs within these
							last few years? </p></div><div n="6" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Can there be a greater or more signal disgrace than for a part of the
							community to be held unworthy of intermarriage, as though contaminated?
							What is this but to suffer exile and banishment within the same walls?
							They are guarding against our becoming connected with them by affinity
							or relationship, against our blood being allied with theirs. </p></div><div n="7" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Why, most of you are descended from Albans and Sabines, and that
							nobility of yours you hold not by birth or blood, but by co-optation
							into the patrician ranks, having been selected for that honour either by
							the kings, or after their expulsion by the mandate of the people. If
							your nobility is tainted by union with us, could you not have kept it
							pure by private regulations, by not seeking brides from the plebs, and
							not suffering your sisters or daughters to marry outside your order?
						</p></div><div n="8" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> No plebeian will offer violence to a patrician maiden, it is the
							patricians who indulge in those criminal practices. </p></div><div n="9" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> None of us would have compelled any one to enter into a marriage
							contract against his will. But, really, that this should be prohibited
							by law and the intermarriage of patricians and plebeians made impossible
							is indeed insulting to the plebs. </p></div><div n="10" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Why do you not combine to forbid intermarriage between rich and poor?
							Everywhere and in all ages there has been an understanding that a woman
							might marry into any house in which she has been betrothed, and a man
							might marry from any house the woman to whom he has become engaged, and
							this understanding you are fettering by the manacles of a most insolent
							law, through which you may break up civil society and rend one State
							into two. </p></div><div n="11" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Why do you not enact a law that no plebeian shall live in the
							neighbourhood of a patrician, or go along the same road, or take his
							place at the same banquet, or stand in the same Forum? For, as a matter
							of fact, what difference is there, if a patrician marries a plebeian
							woman or a plebeian marries a patrician? </p></div><div n="12" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> What rights are infringed, pray? Of course, the children follow the
							father. There is nothing that we are seeking in intermarriage with you,
							except that we may be reckoned amongst men and citizens; there is
							nothing for you to fight about, unless you delight in trying how far you
							can insult and degrade us.” </p></div></div><div n="5" subtype="chapter" type="textpart"><div n="1" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> “In a word, does the supreme power belong to you or to the Roman
							people? Did the expulsion of the kings mean absolute ascendancy for you
							or equal liberty for all? </p></div><div n="2" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Is it right and proper for the Roman people to enact a law, if it wishes
							to do so, or are you going, whenever a measure is proposed, to order a
							levy by way of punishment? Am I to call the tribes up to vote, and as
							soon as I have begun, are you, the consuls, going to compel those who
							are liable for service to take the military oath, and then march them
							off to camp, threatening alike the plebs and the tribunes? </p></div><div n="3" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Why, have you not on two occasions found out what your threats are worth
							against a united plebs? Was it, I wonder, in our interest that you
							abstained from an open conflict, or was it because the stronger party
							was also the more moderate one that there was no fighting? </p></div><div n="4" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Nor will there be any conflict now, Quirites; </p></div><div n="5" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> they will always try your courage, they will not test your
							strength.” “And so, consuls, the plebeians are ready to
							follow you to these wars, whether real or imaginary, on condition that
							by restoring the right of intermarriage you at last make this
							commonwealth a united one, that it be in their power to be allied with
							you by family ties, that the hope of attaining high office be granted to
							men of ability and energy, that it be open to them to be associated with
							you in taking their share of the government, and-which is the essence of
							equal liberty-to rule and obey in turn, in the annual succession of
							magistrates. </p></div><div n="6" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> If any one is going to obstruct these measures, you may talk about wars
							and exaggerate them by rumour, no one is going to give in his name, no
							one is going to take up arms, no one is going to fight for domineering
							masters with whom they have in public life no partnership in honours,
							and in private life no right of intermarriage.” </p></div></div><div n="6" subtype="chapter" type="textpart"><div n="1" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p>After the two consuls had come forward into the Assembly, set speeches
							gave place to a personal altercation. The tribune asked why it was not
							right for a plebeian to be elected consul. </p></div><div n="2" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> The consuls gave a reply which, though perhaps true, was an unfortunate
							one in view of the present controversy. They said, “Because no
							plebeian could have the auspices, and the reason why the decemvirs had
							put an end to intermarriage was to prevent the auspices from being
							vitiated through the uncertainty of descent.” </p></div><div n="3" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> This bitterly exasperated the plebeians, for they believed that they
							were held incompetent to take the auspices because they were hateful to
							the immortal gods. As they had got a most energetic leader in their
							tribune and were supporting him with the utmost determination, the
							controversy ended in the defeat of the patricians. </p></div><div n="4" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> They consented to the intermarriage law being passed, mainly in the
							belief that the tribunes would either abandon the struggle for plebeian
							consuls altogether, or would at least postpone it till after the war,
							and that the plebeians, contented with what they had gained, would be
							ready to enlist. Owing to his victory over the patricians Canuleius was
							now immensely popular. </p></div><div n="5" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Fired by his example, the other tribunes fought with the utmost energy
							to secure the passing of their measure, and though the rumours of war
							became more serious every day they obstructed the enlistment. </p></div><div n="6" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> As no business could be transacted in the senate owing to the
							intervention of the tribunes, the consuls held councils of the leaders
							at their own houses. It was evident that they would have to yield the
							victory either to their foreign foes or to their own countrymen. </p></div><div n="7" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Valerius and Horatius were the only men of consular rank who did not
							attend these councils. C. Claudius was in favour of empowering the
							consuls to use armed force against the tribunes; the Quinctii,
							Cincinnatus and Capitolinus, were averse from bloodshed or injury to
							those whom in their treaty with the plebs they had agreed to hold
							inviolable. The result of their deliberations was that they allowed
							tribunes of the soldiers with consular powers to be elected from the
							patricians and plebeians indiscriminately; </p></div><div n="8" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> no change was made in the election of consuls. This arrangement
							satisfied the tribunes and it satisfied the plebs. Notice was published
							that an Assembly would be held for the election of three tribunes with
							consular powers. </p></div><div n="9" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> No sooner was this announcement made than everybody who had ever acted
							or spoken as a fomenter of sedition, especially those who had been
							tribunes, came forward as candidates, and began to bustle about the
							Forum, canvassing for votes. </p></div><div n="10" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> The patricians were at first deterred from seeking election, as in the
							exasperated mood of the plebeians they regarded their chances as
							hopeless, and they were disgusted at the prospect of having to hold
							office with these men. At last, under compulsion from their leaders,
							lest they should appear to have withdrawn from any share in the
							government, they consented to stand. </p></div><div n="11" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> The result of the election showed that when men are contending for
							liberty and the right to hold office their feelings are different from
							what they are when the contest is over and they can form an unbiased
							judgment. The people were satisfied now that votes were allowed for
							plebeians, and they elected none but patricians. </p></div><div n="12" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Where in these days will you find in a single individual the moderation,
							fairness, and loftiness of mind which then characterised the people as a
							whole? </p></div></div></div></div></body></text></TEI>
                </passage>
            </reply>
            </GetPassage>