<GetPassage xmlns:tei="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0" xmlns="http://chs.harvard.edu/xmlns/cts">
            <request>
                <requestName>GetPassage</requestName>
                <requestUrn>urn:cts:latinLit:phi0914.phi001.perseus-eng3:3.39-3.42</requestUrn>
            </request>
            <reply>
                <urn>urn:cts:latinLit:phi0914.phi001.perseus-eng3:3.39-3.42</urn>
                <passage>
                    <TEI xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><text><body><div n="urn:cts:latinLit:phi0914.phi001.perseus-eng3" type="edition" xml:lang="eng"><div n="3" subtype="book" type="textpart"><div n="39" subtype="chapter" type="textpart"><div n="1" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p>This obedience, however, was shown more by their coming to the
							Senate-house than by any servility in the sentiments which we understand
							that they expressed. </p></div><div n="2" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> It is recorded that after the question of the war had been introduced by
							Appius Claudius, and before the formal discussion began,<note anchored="true" n="19" resp="ed" place="unspecified">The president
								introduced the question and each senator was asked by him in turn to
								express his opinion. Valerius was out of order.</note> L. Valerius
							Potitus created a scene by demanding that he should be allowed to speak
							on the political question, and on the decemvirs forbidding him in
							threatening tones to do so, he declared that he would present himself
							before the people. </p></div><div n="3" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Marcus Horatius Barbatus showed himself an equally determined opponent,
							called the decemvirs “ten Tarquins,” and reminded them
							that it was under the leadership of the Valerii and the Horatii that
							monarchy had been expelled from <placeName key="perseus,Rome">Rome</placeName>. </p></div><div n="4" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> It was not the name of “king” that men had now grown weary
							of, for it was the proper title of <placeName key="tgn,1125260">Jupiter</placeName>, Romulus the founder of the City and his
							successors were called “kings,” and the name was still
							retained for religious purposes. </p></div><div n="5" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> It was the tyranny and violence of kings that men detested. If these
							were insupportable in a king or a king's son, who would endure them in
							ten private citizens? </p></div><div n="6" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> They should see to it that they did not, by forbidding freedom of speech
							in the House, compel them to speak outside its walls. He could not see
							how it was less permissible for him as a private citizen to convene an
							Assembly of the people than for them to summon the senate. </p></div><div n="7" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> They might find out whenever they chose how much more powerful a sense
							of wrong is to vindicate liberty than greedy ambition is to support
							tyranny. </p></div><div n="8" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> They were bringing up the question of the <placeName key="tgn,7021127">Sabine</placeName> war as if the Roman people had any more serious
							war to wage than one against men who, appointed to draw up laws, left no
							vestige of law or justice in the State; who had abolished the elections,
							the annual magistrates, the regular succession of rulers, which formed
							the sole guarantee of equal liberty for all; who, though simple
							citizens, still retained the <foreign xml:lang="lat">fasces</foreign> and the
							power of despotic monarchs. </p></div><div n="9" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> After the expulsion of the kings, the magistrates were patricians; after
							the secession of the plebs, plebeian magistrates were appointed.
							“What party did these men belong to?”he asked. “The
							popular party? Why, what have they ever done in conjunction with the
							people? The nobility? What! these men, who have not held a meeting of
							the senate for nearly a year, and now that they are holding one, forbid
							any speaking on the political situation? </p></div><div n="10" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Do not place too much reliance on the fears of others. The ills that men
							are actually suffering from seem to them much more grievous than any
							they may fear in the future.” </p></div></div><div n="40" subtype="chapter" type="textpart"><div n="1" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p>Whilst Horatius was delivering this impassioned speech, and the decemvirs
							were in doubt how far they ought to go, whether in the direction of
							angry resistance </p></div><div n="2" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> or in that of concession, and unable to see what the issue would be, C.
							Claudius, the uncle of the decemvir Appius, made a speech more in the
							nature of entreaty than of censure. </p></div><div n="3" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> He implored him by the shade of his father to think rather of the social
							order under which he had been born than of the nefarious compact made
							with his colleagues. </p></div><div n="4" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> It was much more, he said, for the sake of Appius than of the State that
							he made this appeal, for the State would assert its rights in spite of
							them, if it could not do so with their consent. But great controversies
							generally kindle great and bitter passions, and it was what these might
							lead to that he dreaded. </p></div><div n="5" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p>Though the decemvirs forbade the discussion of any subject save the one
							they had introduced, their respect for Claudius prevented them from
							interrupting him, so he concluded with a resolution that no decree
							should be passed by the senate. </p></div><div n="6" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> This was universally taken to mean that Claudius adjudged them to be
							private citizens, and many of the consulars expressed their concurrence.
						</p></div><div n="7" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Another proposal, apparently more drastic, but in reality less
							effective, was that the senate should order the patricians to hold a
							special meeting to appoint an “ <foreign xml:lang="lat">interrex</foreign>.” For by voting for this, they decided
							that those who were presiding over the senate were lawful magistrates,
							whoever they were, whereas the proposal that no decree should be passed
							made them private citizens. </p></div><div n="8" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p>The cause of the decemvirs was on the point of collapsing, when L.
							Cornelius Maluginensis, the brother of M. Cornelius the decemvir, who
							had been purposely selected from among the consulars to wind up the
							debate, undertook to defend his brother and his brother's colleagues by
							professing great anxiety about the war. </p></div><div n="9" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> He was wondering, he said, by what fatality it had come about that the
							decemvirs should be attacked by those who had sought the </p></div><div n="10" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> office or by their allies or in particular by these men,<note anchored="true" n="20" resp="ed" place="unspecified">i. e. Horatius
								and Valerius.</note> or why, during all the months that the
							commonwealth was undisturbed, no one questioned whether those at the
							head of affairs were lawful magistrates or not, whereas now, when the
							enemy were almost at their gates, they were fomenting civic discord
							—unless indeed they supposed that the nature of their proceeding would
							be less apparent in the general confusion. </p></div><div n="11" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> No one was justified in importing prejudice into a matter of such moment
							whilst they were preoccupied with much more serious anxieties. He gave
							it as his opinion that the point raised by Valerius and Horatius,
							namely, that the decemvirs had ceased to hold office by May 15, should
							be submitted to the senate for decision after the impending wars had
							been brought to a close and the tranquillity of the State restored. </p></div><div n="12" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> And further, that Ap. Claudius must at once understand that he must be
							prepared to make a proper return of the election which he held for the
							appointment of decemvirs, stating whether they were elected only for a
							year, or until such time as the laws which were still required should be
							passed. </p></div><div n="13" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> In his opinion every matter but the war should for the present be laid
							aside. If they thought that the reports of it which had got abroad were
							false, and that not only the messengers which had come in but even the
							Tuscan envoys had invented the story, then they ought to send out
							reconnoitring parties to bring back accurate information. </p></div><div n="14" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> If, however, they believed the messengers and the envoys, a levy ought
							to be made at the earliest possible moment, the decemvirs should lead
							the armies in whatever direction each thought best, and nothing else
							should take precedence. </p></div></div><div n="41" subtype="chapter" type="textpart"><div n="1" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p>Whilst a division was being taken and the younger senators were carrying
							this proposition, Valerius and Horatius rose again in great excitement
							and loudly demanded leave to discuss the political situation. If, they
							said, the faction in the senate prevented them, they would bring it
							before the people, for private citizens had no power to silence them
							either in the Senate-house or in the Assembly, and they were not going
							to give way before the <foreign xml:lang="lat">fasces</foreign> of a mock
							authority. </p></div><div n="2" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Appius felt that unless he met their violence with equal audacity, his
							authority was practically at an end. </p></div><div n="3" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> “It will be better,” he said, “not to speak on any
							subject but the one we are now considering,” and as Valerius
							insisted that he should not keep silent for a private citizen, Appius
							ordered a lictor to go to him. </p></div><div n="4" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Valerius ran to the doors of the Senate-house and invoked “the
							protection of the Quirites.” L. Cornelius put an end to the scene
							by throwing his arms round Appius as though to protect Valerius, but
							really to protect Appius from further mischief. He obtained permission
							for Valerius to say what he wanted, and as this liberty did not go
							beyond words, the decemvirs achieved their purpose. </p></div><div n="5" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> The consulars and senior senators felt that the tribunitian authority,
							which they still regarded with detestation, was much more eagerly
							desired by the plebs than the restoration of the consular authority, and
							they would almost rather have had the decemvirs voluntarily resigning
							office at a subsequent period than that the plebs should recover power
							through their unpopularity. </p></div><div n="6" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> If matters could be quietly arranged and the consuls restored without
							any popular disturbance, they thought that either the preoccupation of
							war or the moderate exercise of power on the part of the consuls would
							make the plebs forget all about their tribunes. </p></div><div n="7" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p>The levy was proclaimed without any protest from the senate. The men of
							age for active service answered to their names, as there was no appeal
							from the authority of the decemvirs. When the legions were enrolled, the
							decemvirs arranged among themselves their respective commands. </p></div><div n="8" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> The prominent men amongst them were Q. Fabius and Appius Claudius. The
							war at home threatened to be more serious than the one abroad, and the
							violent disposition of Appius was deemed more fitted to repress
							commotions in the City, whilst Fabius was looked upon as more inclined
							to evil practices than to be any permanent good to them. </p></div><div n="9" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> This man, at one time so distinguished both at home and in the field,
							had been so changed by office and the influence of his colleagues that
							he preferred to take Appius as his model rather than be true to himself.
						</p></div><div n="10" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> He was entrusted with the <placeName key="tgn,7021127">Sabine</placeName> war, and Manlius Rabuleius and Q. Poetilius were
							associated with him in its conduct. M. Cornelius was sent to Algidus,
							together with L. Minucius, T. Antonius, Kaeso Duillius, and M. Sergius.
							It was decreed that Sp. Oppius should assist Ap. Claudius in the defence
							of the City, with an authority coordinate with that of the other
							decemvirs. </p></div></div><div n="42" subtype="chapter" type="textpart"><div n="1" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p><note anchored="true" type="sum" resp="ed" place="unspecified">War with
								the Aequi and Sabines.</note>The military operations were not any
							more satisfactory than the domestic administration. </p></div><div n="2" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> The commanders were certainly at fault in having made themselves objects
							of detestation to the citizens, but otherwise the whole of the blame
							rested on the soldiers, who, to prevent anything from succeeding under
							the auspices and leadership of the decemvirs, disgraced both themselves
							and their generals by allowing themselves to be defeated. </p></div><div n="3" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> Both armies had been routed, the one by the Sabines at Eretum, the other
							by the Aequi on Algidus. Fleeing from Eretum in the silence of the
							night, they had entrenched themselves on some high ground near the City
							between Fidenae and Crustumeria. </p></div><div n="4" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> They refused to meet the pursuing enemy anywhere on equal terms, and
							trusted for safety to their entrenchments and the nature of the ground,
							not to arms or courage. </p></div><div n="5" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> On Algidus they behaved more disgracefully, suffered a heavier defeat,
							and even lost their camp. Deprived of all their stores, the soldiers
							made their way to <placeName key="tgn,2734588">Tusculum</placeName>,
							looking for subsistence to the good faith and compassion of their hosts,
							and their confidence was not misplaced. </p></div><div n="6" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p>Such alarming reports were brought to <placeName key="tgn,7013962">Rome</placeName> that the senate, laying aside their feeling
							against the decemvirs, resolved that guards should be mounted in the
							City, ordered that all who were of age to bear arms should man the walls
							and undertake outpost duty before the gates, and decreed a supply of
							arms to be sent to <placeName key="tgn,2101894">Tusculum</placeName> to
							replace those which had been lost, whilst the decemvirs were to evacuate
								<placeName key="tgn,2101894">Tusculum</placeName> and keep their
							soldiers encamped. </p></div><div n="7" subtype="section" type="textpart"><p> The other camp was to be transferred from Fidenae on to the <placeName key="tgn,7021127">Sabine</placeName> territory, and by assuming the
							offensive deter the enemy from any project of attacking the City. </p></div></div></div></div></body></text></TEI>
                </passage>
            </reply>
            </GetPassage>