<GetPassage xmlns:tei="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0" xmlns="http://chs.harvard.edu/xmlns/cts">
            <request>
                <requestName>GetPassage</requestName>
                <requestUrn>urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0004.tlg001.perseus-eng2:1.prol.21-1.1.40</requestUrn>
            </request>
            <reply>
                <urn>urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0004.tlg001.perseus-eng2:1.prol.21-1.1.40</urn>
                <passage>
                    <TEI xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><text><body><div type="translation" n="urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0004.tlg001.perseus-eng2" xml:lang="eng"><div type="textpart" subtype="book" xml:base="urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0004.tlg001.perseus-eng2" n="1"><div type="textpart" subtype="chapter" xml:base="urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0004.tlg001.perseus-eng2:1" n="prol"><div type="textpart" subtype="section" xml:base="urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0004.tlg001.perseus-eng2:1.prol" n="21"><p rend="align(indent)">One word more: not long ago an Eclectic school was introduced by Potamo of Alexandria,<note resp="editor">Certainly not the same as the person mentioned by Porphyry in his <title rend="italic">Life of Plotinus,</title> 9, 11, for Polemo, not Potamo, is the correct form of the name in that place. Potamo is said by Suidas (<foreign xml:lang="lat">s.v.</foreign> <foreign xml:lang="grc">Ποτάμων Ἀλ.</foreign>) to have lived shortly before and contemporary with Augustus, whence it follows that Diogenes has taken without alteration a statement by an earlier writer who might truthfully say <q>not long ago</q> of the reign of Augustus. Suidas, whose article <foreign xml:lang="grc">αἵρεσις</foreign> agrees closely with our text, naturally omits <foreign xml:lang="grc">πρὸ ὀλίγου.</foreign></note>, who <pb n="V1_23"/> made a selection from the tenets of all the existing sects. As he himself states in his <title rend="italic">Elements of Philosophy,</title> he takes as criteria of truth (1) that by which the judgement is formed, namely, the ruling principle of the soul; (2) the instrument used, for instance the most accurate perception. His universal principles are matter and the efficient cause, quality, and place; for that out of which and that by which a thing is made, as well as the quality with which and the place in which it is made, are principles. The end to which he refers all actions is life made perfect in all virtue, natural advantages of body and environment being indispensable to its attainment.</p><p rend="align(indent)">It remains to speak of the philosophers themselves, and in the first place of Thales.</p></div></div><div type="textpart" subtype="chapter" xml:base="urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0004.tlg001.perseus-eng2:1" n="1"><head rend="align(center)">Chapter 1. THALES (floruit circa 585 B.C., the date of the eclipse)</head><div type="textpart" subtype="section" xml:base="urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0004.tlg001.perseus-eng2:1.1" n="22"><p rend="align(indent)">Herodotus, Duris, and Democritus are agreed that Thales was the son of Examyas and Cleobulina, and belonged to the Thelidae<note resp="editor">Nelidac, if Bywater’s emendation is correct.</note> who are Phoenicians, and among the noblest of the descendants of Cadmus and Agenor. As Plato testifies, he was one of the Seven Sages. He was the first to receive the name of Sage, in the archonship of Damasias<note resp="editor">582 b.c.</note> at Athens, when the term was applied to all the Seven Sages, as Demetrius of Phalerum mentions in his <title rend="italic">List of Archons.</title> He was admitted to citizenship at Miletus when he came to that town along with Nileos, who had been expelled from Phoenicia. Most writers, however, represent him as a genuine Milesian and of a distinguished family.</p></div><pb n="V1_25"/><div type="textpart" subtype="section" xml:base="urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0004.tlg001.perseus-eng2:1.1" n="23"><p rend="align(indent)">After engaging in politics he became a student of nature. According to some he left nothing in writing; for the <title rend="italic">Nautical Astronomy</title><note resp="editor"><foreign xml:lang="lat">Cf.</foreign> Simplicius, <title rend="italic">In Phys.</title> i. 23, 29-33 d.</note> attributed to him is said to be by Phocus of Samos. Callimachus knows him as the discoverer of the Ursa Minor; for he says in his <title rend="italic">Iambics</title>:
<quote rend="blockquote">Who first of men the course made plain
	<l/>Of those small stars we call the Wain,
	<l/>Whereby Phoenicians sail the main.<note resp="editor">Greek mariners steered by the Great Bear, the Phoenicians by the Little Bear, as Ovid states, <title rend="italic">Tristia</title>, iv. 3. 1, 2.</note>.</quote>
	But according to others he wrote nothing but two treatises, one <title rend="italic">On the Solstice</title> and one <title rend="italic">On the Equinox</title>, regarding all other matters as incognizable. He seems by some accounts to have been the first to study astronomy,<note resp="editor">See Sir T. L. Heath, <title rend="italic">Aristarchus of Samos</title>, pp. 12-23.</note>, the first to predict eclipses of the sun and to fix the solstices; so Eudemus in his <title rend="italic">History of Astronomy.</title> It was this which gained for him the admiration of Xenophanes and Herodotus and the notice of Heraclitus and Democritus.</p></div><div type="textpart" subtype="section" xml:base="urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0004.tlg001.perseus-eng2:1.1" n="24"><p rend="align(indent)">And some, including Choerilus the poet, declare that he was the first to maintain the immortality of the soul. He was the first to determine the sun’s course from solstice to solstice, and according to some the first to declare the size of the sun to be one seven hundred and twentieth part of the solar circle, and the size of the moon to be the same fraction of the lunar circle. He was the first to give the last day of the month the name of Thirtieth, and the first, some say, to discuss physical problems.</p><p rend="align(indent)">Aristotle<note resp="editor"><title rend="italic">De anima</title>, A 2, 405 a 19.</note> and Hippias affirm that, arguing from the magnet and from amber, he attributed a soul or life even to inanimate objects. Pamphila states that, <pb n="V1_27"/> having learnt geometry from the Egyptians, he was the first to inscribe a right-angled triangle in a circle, whereupon he sacrificed an ox. </p></div><div type="textpart" subtype="section" xml:base="urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0004.tlg001.perseus-eng2:1.1" n="25"><p>Others tell this tale of Pythagoras, amongst them Apollodorus the arithmetician. (It was Pythagoras who developed to their furthest extent the discoveries attributed by Callimachus in his <title rend="italic">Iambics</title> to Euphorbus the Phrygian, I mean <q>scalene triangles</q> and whatever else has to do with theoretical geometry.<note resp="editor"><foreign xml:lang="lat">i.e.</foreign> a theory concerned with lines, <foreign xml:lang="grc">γραμμαί,</foreign> which of course include curves as well as straight lines.</note>)</p><p rend="align(indent)">Thales is also credited with having given excellent advice on political matters. For instance, when Croesus sent to Miletus offering terms of alliance, he frustrated the plan; and this proved the salvation of the city when Cyrus obtained the victory. Heraclides makes Thales himself<note resp="editor">Namely, in a dialogue. <foreign xml:lang="lat">Cf.</foreign> viii. 4.</note> say that he had always lived in solitude as a private individual and kept aloof from State affairs. </p></div><div type="textpart" subtype="section" xml:base="urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0004.tlg001.perseus-eng2:1.1" n="26"><p>Some authorities say that he married and had a son Cybisthus; others that he remained unmarried and adopted his sister’s son, and that when he was asked why he had no children of his own he replied <q>because he loved children.</q> The story is told that, when his mother tried to force him to marry, he replied it was too soon, and when she pressed him again later in life, he replied that it was too late. Hieronymus of Rhodes in the second book of his <title rend="italic">Scattered Notes</title> relates that, in order to show how easy it is to grow rich, Thales, foreseeing that it would be a good season for olives, rented all the oil-mills and thus amassed a fortune.<note resp="editor">Because, having created a monopoly, he could charge what he pleased. See Aristotle’s version of the story, <title rend="italic">Pol.</title> i. 11, 1259 a 6-18.</note></p></div><div type="textpart" subtype="section" xml:base="urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0004.tlg001.perseus-eng2:1.1" n="27"><p rend="align(indent)">His doctrine was that water is the universal primary substance, and that the world is animate and full of divinities. He is said to have discovered <pb n="V1_29"/> the seasons of the year and divided it into 365 days.</p><p rend="align(indent)">He had no instructor, except that he went to Egypt and spent some time with the priests there. Hieronymus informs us that he measured the height of the pyramids by the shadow they cast, taking the observation at the hour when our shadow is of the same length as ourselves. He lived, as Minyas relates, with Thrasybulus, the tyrant of Miletus.</p><p rend="align(indent)">The well-known story of the tripod found by the fishermen and sent by the people of Miletus to all the Wise Men in succession runs as follows. </p></div><div type="textpart" subtype="section" xml:base="urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0004.tlg001.perseus-eng2:1.1" n="28"><p> Certain Ionian youths having purchased of the Milesian fishermen their catch of fish, a dispute arose over the tripod which had formed part of the catch. Finally the Milesians referred the question to Delphi, and the god gave an oracle in this form<note resp="editor"><title rend="italic">Anth. Plan.</title> vi. 51.</note>:
<quote rend="blockquote">Who shall possess the tripod? Thus replies
	<l/>Apollo: <q>Whosoever is most wise.</q><note resp="editor">Or in prose: <q>Offspring of Miletus, do you ask Phoebus concerning the tripod? Whoso in wisdom is of all the first, to him the tripod I adjudge.</q></note></quote>
Accordingly they give it to Thales, and he to another, and so on till it comes to Solon, who, with the remark that the god was the most wise, sent it off to Delphi. Callimachus in his <title rend="italic">Iambics</title> has a different version of the story, which he took from Maeandrius of Miletus.<note resp="editor">Although disguised as Leandrius, the writer meant is Maeandrius, who is known (<title rend="italic">Inscr. Gr.</title> no. 2905) to have written a local history of Miletus. Such histories, <foreign xml:lang="lat">etg.</foreign> of Sicyon, Megara, Samos, Naxos, Argolis, Epirus, Thessaly, abounded in the Alexandrian age.</note> It is that Bathycles, an Arcadian, left at his death a bowl with the solemn injunction that it <q>should be given to him who had done most good by his wisdom.</q> So it was given to Thales, went the round of all the sages, and came back to Thales again. </p></div><div type="textpart" subtype="section" xml:base="urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0004.tlg001.perseus-eng2:1.1" n="29"><p>And he sent it <pb n="V1_31"/> to Apollo at Didyma, with this dedication, according to Callimachus:
<quote rend="blockquote">Lord of the folk of Neleus’ line, 
<l/>Thales, of Greeks adjudged most wise,
<l/>Brings to thy Didymaean shrine
<l/>His offering, a twice-won prize.</quote>
But the prose inscription is: 
<quote rend="align(indent)">Thales the Milesian, son of Examyas [dedicates this] to Delphinian Apollo after twice winning the prize from all the Greeks.</quote> 
The bowl was carried from place to place by the son of Bathycles, whose name was Thyrion, so it is stated by Eleusis in his work <title rend="italic">On Achilles,</title> and Alexo the Myndian in the ninth book of his <title rend="italic">Legends.</title></p><p rend="align(indent)">But Eudoxus of Cnidos and Euanthes of Miletus agree that a certain man who was a friend of Croesus received from the king a golden goblet in order to bestow it upon the wisest of the Greeks; this man gave it to Thales, and from him it passed to others and so to Chilon.</p></div><div type="textpart" subtype="section" xml:base="urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0004.tlg001.perseus-eng2:1.1" n="30"><p rend="align(indent)">Chilon laid the question <q>Who is a wiser man than I?</q> before the Pythian Apollo, and the god replied <q>Myson.</q> Of him we shall have more to say presently. (In the list of the Seven Sages given by Eudoxus, Myson takes the place of Cleobulus; Plato also includes him by omitting Periander.) The answer of the oracle respecting him was as follows<note resp="editor"><title rend="italic">Anth. Plan.</title> vi. 40.</note>: 
<quote rend="blockquote"><l/>Myson of Chen in Oeta; this is he 
<l/>Who for wiseheartedness surpasseth thee;</quote>
and it was given in reply to a question put by Anacharsis. Daimachus the Platonist and Clearchus allege that a bowl was sent by Croesus to Pittacus and began the round of the Wise Men from him.</p><pb n="V1_33"/><p>The story told by Andron<note resp="editor">Andron of Ephesus (§119) is known to have written in the life-time (or at least before the death) of Theopompus, who is accused of having plagiarized from <title rend="italic">The Tripod</title>: Eusebius, <title rend="italic">Praep. Ev.</title> x. 3, 7.</note> in his work on <title rend="italic">The Tripod</title> is that the Argives offered a tripod as a prize of virtue to the wisest of the Greeks; Aristodemus of Sparta was adjudged the winner but retired in favour of Chilon. </p></div><div type="textpart" subtype="section" xml:base="urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0004.tlg001.perseus-eng2:1.1" n="31"><p>Aristodemus is mentioned by Alcaeus thus<note resp="editor">Fr. 49 Bergk; <foreign xml:lang="lat">cf.</foreign> <title rend="italic">Schol.</title> Pindar, <title rend="italic">Isthm.</title> ii. 17.</note>:
<quote rend="blockquote">Surely no witless word was this of the Spartan, I deem,
<l/><q>Wealth is the worth of a man; and poverty void of esteem.</q></quote>
Some relate that a vessel with its freight was sent by Periander to Thrasybulus, tyrant of Miletus, and that, when it was wrecked in Coan waters, the tripod was afterwards found by certain fishermen. However, Phanodicus declares it to have been found in Athenian waters and thence brought to Athens. An assembly was held and it was sent to Bias; </p></div><div type="textpart" subtype="section" xml:base="urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0004.tlg001.perseus-eng2:1.1" n="32"><p> for what reason shall be explained in the life of Bias.</p><p rend="align(indent)">There is yet another version, that it was the work of Hephaestus presented by the god to Pelops on his marriage. Thence it passed to Menelaus and was carried off by Paris along with Helen and was thrown by her into the Coan sea, for she said it would be a cause of strife. In process of time certain people of Lebedus, having purchased a catch of fish thereabouts, obtained possession of the tripod, and, quarrelling with the fishermen about it, put in to Cos, and, when they could not settle the dispute, reported the fact to Miletus, their mother-city. The Milesians, when their embassies were disregarded, made war upon Cos; many fell on both sides, and an oracle pronounced that the tripod <pb n="V1_35"/> should be given to the wisest; both parties to the dispute agreed upon Thales. After it had gone the round of the sages, Thales dedicated it to Apollo of Didyma. </p></div><div type="textpart" subtype="section" xml:base="urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0004.tlg001.perseus-eng2:1.1" n="33"><p>The oracle which the Coans received was on this wise:
<quote rend="blockquote">Hephaestus cast the tripod in the sea; 
<l/>Until it quit the city there will be
<l/>No end to strife, until it reach the seer
<l/>Whose wisdom makes past, present, future clear.</quote> 
That of the Milesians beginning <q>Who shall possess the tripod?</q> has been quoted above. So much for this version of the story. </p><p rend="align(indent)">Hermippus in his <title rend="italic">Lives</title> refers to Thales the story which is told by some of Socrates, namely, that he used to say there were three blessings for which he was grateful to Fortune: <q>first, that I was born a human being and not one of the brutes; next, that I was born a man and not a woman; thirdly, a Greek and not a barbarian.</q> </p></div><div type="textpart" subtype="section" xml:base="urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0004.tlg001.perseus-eng2:1.1" n="34"><p>It is said that once, when he was taken out of doors by an old woman in order that he might observe the stars, he fell into a ditch, and his cry for help drew from the old woman the retort, <q>How can you expect to know all about the heavens, Thales, when you cannot even see what is just before your feet?</q> Timon too knows him as an astronomer, and praises him in the <title rend="italic">Silli</title> where he says<note resp="editor">Fr. 23 Diels.</note>: 
<quote rend="blockquote">Thales among the Seven the sage astronomer.</quote> </p><p rend="align(indent)">His writings are said by Lobon of Argos to have run to some two hundred lines. His statue is said to bear this inscription<note resp="editor"><title rend="italic">Anth. Pal.</title> vii. 83.</note>: <pb n="V1_37"/> 
<quote rend="blockquote">Pride of Miletus and Ionian lands,
<l/>Wisest astronomer, here Thales stands.</quote> </p></div><div type="textpart" subtype="section" xml:base="urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0004.tlg001.perseus-eng2:1.1" n="35"><p>Of songs still sung these verses belong to him:
<quote rend="blockquote">Many words do not declare an understanding heart.
<l/>Seek one sole wisdom. 
<l/>Choose one sole good.
<l/>For thou wilt check the tongues of chatterers prating without end.</quote></p><p rend="align(indent)">Here too are certain current apophthegms assigned to him:
<quote rend="blockquote">Of all things that are, the most ancient is God, for he is uncreated.
<l/>The most beautiful is the universe, for it is God’s workmanship.
<l/>The greatest is space, for it holds all things. 
<l/>The swiftest is mind, for it speeds everywhere.
<l/>The strongest, necessity, for it masters all. 
<l/>The wisest, time, for it brings everything to light.</quote> 
He held there was no difference between life and death. <q>Why then,</q> said one, <q>do you not die?</q> <q>Because,</q> said he, <q>there is no difference.</q> </p></div><div type="textpart" subtype="section" xml:base="urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0004.tlg001.perseus-eng2:1.1" n="36"><p>To the question which is older, day or night, he replied: <q>Night is the older by one day.</q> Some one asked him whether a man could hide an evil deed from the gods: <q>No,</q> he replied, <q>nor yet an evil thought.</q> To the adulterer who inquired if he should deny the charge upon oath he replied that perjury was no worse than adultery. Being asked what is difficult, he replied, <q>To know oneself.</q> <q>What is easy?</q> <q>To give advice to another.</q> <q>What is most pleasant?</q> <q>Success.</q> <q>What is the divine?</q> <q>That which has neither beginning nor end.</q> To the question what was the strangest <pb n="V1_39"/> thing he had ever seen, his answer was, <q>An aged tyrant.</q> <q>How can one best bear adversity?</q> <q>If he should see his enemies in worse plight.</q> <q>How shall we lead the best and most righteous life?</q> <q>By refraining from doing what we blame in others.</q> </p></div><div type="textpart" subtype="section" xml:base="urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0004.tlg001.perseus-eng2:1.1" n="37"><p><q>What man is happy?</q><q>He who has a healthy body, a resourceful mind and a docile nature.</q> He tells us to remember friends, whether present or absent; not to pride ourselves upon outward appearance, but to study to be beautiful in character. <q>Shun ill-gotten gains,</q> he says. <q>Let not idle words prejudice thee against those who have shared thy confidence.</q> <q>Whatever provision thou hast made for thy parents, the same must thou expect from thy children.</q> He explained the overflow of the Nile as due to the etesian winds which, blowing in the contrary direction, drove the waters upstream.</p><p rend="align(indent)">Apollodorus in his <title rend="italic">Chronology</title> places his birth in the first year of the 35th Olympiad [640 B.C.]. </p></div><div type="textpart" subtype="section" xml:base="urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0004.tlg001.perseus-eng2:1.1" n="38"><p>He died at the age of 78 (or, according to Sosicrates, of 90 years); for he died in the 58th Olympiad, being contemporary with Croesus, whom he undertook to take across the Halys without building a bridge, by diverting the river.</p><p rend="align(indent)">There have lived five other men who bore the name of Thales, as enumerated by Demetrius of Magnesia in his <title rend="italic">Dictionary of Men of the Same Name:</title>
	<l rend="align(indent)">1. A rhetorician of Callatia, with an affected style.</l> 
	<l rend="align(indent)">2. A painter of Sicyon, of great gifts.</l> 
	<l rend="align(indent)">3. A contemporary of Hesiod, Homer and Lycurgus, in very early times.</l> 
	<l rend="align(indent)">4. A person mentioned by Duris in his work <title rend="italic">On Painting.</title></l> <pb n="V1_41"/> 
	<l rend="align(indent)">5. An obscure person in more recent times who is mentioned by Dionysius in his <title rend="italic">Critical Writings.</title></l></p></div><div type="textpart" subtype="section" xml:base="urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0004.tlg001.perseus-eng2:1.1" n="39"><p rend="align(indent)">Thales the Sage died as he was watching an athletic contest from heat, thirst, and the weakness incident to advanced age. And the inscription on his tomb is<note resp="editor"><title rend="italic">Anth. Pal.</title> vii. 84.</note>:
<quote rend="blockquote">Here in a narrow tomb great Thales lies; 
<l/>Yet his renown for wisdom reached the skies.</quote> 
I may also cite one of my own, from my first book, <title rend="italic">Epigrams in Various Metres</title><note resp="editor"><title rend="italic">Anth. Pal.</title> vii. 85.</note>: 
<quote rend="blockquote">As Thales watched the games one festal day
<l/>The fierce sun smote him, and he passed away;
<l/>Zeus, thou didst well to raise him; his dim eyes
<l/>Could not from earth behold the starry skies.<note resp="editor">In plain prose: <q>As the wise Thales was one day watching the contest of the racers, thou, O Sun-god, O Zeus, didst snatch him from the stadium. I praise thee for removing him to be near thee; for verily the old man could no more discern the stars from earth.</q></note></quote></p></div><div type="textpart" subtype="section" xml:base="urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0004.tlg001.perseus-eng2:1.1" n="40"><p rend="align(indent)">To him belongs the proverb <q>Know thyself,</q> which Antisthenes in his <title rend="italic">Successions of Philosophers</title> attributes to Phemonoë, though admitting that it was appropriated by Chilon.</p><p rend="align(indent)">This seems the proper place for a general notice of the Seven Sages, of whom we have such accounts as the following. Damon of Cyrene in his <title rend="italic">History of the Philosophers</title> carps at all sages, but especially the Seven. Anaximenes remarks that they all applied themselves to poetry; Dicaearchus that they were neither sages nor philosophers, but merely <pb n="V1_43"/> shrewd men with a turn for legislation.<note resp="editor">The opinion of Dicaearchus thus expressed is correct. With the exception of Thales, no one whose life is contained in Book I. has any claim to be styled a philosopher. The tradition of the Seven Wise Men and of their meeting at some court, whether of a native tyrant like Periander or of a foreign prince like Croesus, was used by Plato (<title rend="italic">Protag.</title> 343 A) and, largely through his influence, grew into a romantic legend, the result being late biographies, collections of apophthegms, and letters attributed to various authors, <foreign xml:lang="lat">e.g.</foreign> the apophthegms of Demetrius of Phalerum. Diogenes Laertius swallows all this as true; modern criticism rejects it all as forgery.</note> Archetimus of Syracuse describes their meeting at the court of Cypselus, on which occasion he himself happened to be present; for which Ephorus substitutes a meeting without Thales at the court of Croesus. Some make them meet at the Pan-Ionian festival, at Corinth, and at Delphi. </p></div></div></div></div></body></text></TEI>
                </passage>
            </reply>
            </GetPassage>